Friday, April 4, 2025
Home Blog Page 160

Non-farm payrolls in focus again

0

US economic data releases are always important. This week, the non-farm payroll number could give us a sign of a slowing economy. The team from TreasuryONE helps us understand the macroeconomic mood out there.

Last week we saw a shift in the Fed’s recent rhetoric – even though the Fed hiked rates by 75 basis points, the Fed stated that while they are approaching the neutral rate, hikes will now be done on a data-dependent scale. In the immediate aftermath of the slight change in the Fed’s rhetoric the US dollar weakened, which gave a much-needed shot in the arm to EM currencies, and the rand strengthened all the way back to the R16.40 level.

Another data set that came out last week was the Advance 2nd Quarter GDP, which showed the US economy had a negative growth quarter – the second quarter in a row where negative growth was seen. This immediately gave rise to the recession question which will be on the watch with every subsequent data release going forward. With the economy slowing down, it will definitely start feeding into the Fed thinking and hikes could be less going forward should the impact remain significant.

One area where the growth slowdown in the US, Europe, and China has had an effect is the commodity sector. We have seen a rise in the gold price instead of the US dollar after the fear of recession in the US and also the oil price slowly trickling down with less demand expected for the commodity. Brent Crude is below the $100 level and we could see the price struggling to reach the previous highs as demand falls away.

Brent Crude

Now that the US economy is in focus again, all eyes will be on any US economic data set in order to understand the state of the US economy. We will see other data apart from inflation drive the market and with this week’s non-farm payroll number we could see the first signs of the slowing economy in the employment sector. We can expect any adverse number on Friday will impact the US dollar and therefore the rand.

The rand will be a passenger this week with any move in the US dollar translating into some rand movement. We do expect the rand moves to be constrained a little due to the elevated commodity prices, and we do believe the rand is quite happy between the R16.50/80 range as it has failed quite a few times in breaking below R16.40. However, any move above R16.80 should be seen as a definite selling opportunity.

USD:ZAR

TreasuryONE provides daily updates in the Ghost Mail morning mailer (subscribe here). Visit TreasuryONE’s website for more information on market risk management, treasury services and more.

Ghost Bites Vol 61 (22)

Corporate finance corner (M&A / capital raises)

Financial updates

  • Massmart (or Messmart as I generally call it) has released another horrible set of numbers. Sales from continuing operations only increased by 1.9% and General Merchandise sales fell by 1.4%, so gross margin has almost certainly taken a knock (we will find out when results are released). The headline loss per share doesn’t give you a sense of the scale of the pain being experienced, so I’ll give you the total headline loss instead from continuing operations: between R885.7 million and R921.5 million. This is an interim loss and is truly awful, even if there are some once-offs in the numbers. I wrote a feature article on this update that you can read here.
  • Telkom has released a trading update for the quarter ended June 2022. Sadly, the most important numbers (revenue and EBITDA) went the wrong way. Revenue is down 3.2% and group EBITDA fell by 15.2%. It’s really not easy for telecoms businesses to do well. For example, data usage didn’t grow by enough to offset the impact of lower data pricing, so the net impact on revenue is negative. Here’s the really interesting thing in case you missed it: MTN is considering a buyout offer for Telkom. Nothing has been confirmed yet but there are clearly serious discussions behind closed doors. To help you understand the Telkom numbers and what MTN might be thinking here, I wrote a feature article on the quarterly update.
  • Royal Bafokeng Platinum has released interim results for the six months ended June 2022 and as we have seen in other PGM businesses, the numbers are down. The market knew this already because anyone can observe the PGM prices in the market, so the share price only closed 2% lower despite a 38.1% decrease in EBITDA and a 58.1% decrease in headline earnings per share (HEPS). Production of 4E ounces increased by 4.5% and the cash operating cost per 4E ounce jumped by an unpleasant 15.2%. The company is disappointed with its production numbers, noting various operational challenges (and Eskom-related issues) at Styldrift. An interim dividend of 245 cents per share has been declared, 54.2% lower than in the comparable period.
  • MTN Ghana has released results for the six months to June 2022. There’s solid growth in this business, with mobile subscribers up 11.6% and active data subscribers up 15.1%. The number of Mobile Money users increased by 11%. With underlying numbers like these, it’s not surprising to see service revenue up by 28.9% and EBITDA margin heading in the right direction, up by 300 basis points to a delicious 57.4%. EBITDA was 36% higher year-on-year, a terrific growth rate. Profit after tax increased by 54.1% as the full benefit of strong revenue growth worked its way down the income statement. Total capital expenditure increased by 98.7%, in line with what we are seeing in the other African subsidiaries that are pumping money into their networks. A challenge in Ghana has been the introduction of a levy on mobile money transactions, which has impacted growth as well as MTN’s margins because the company cut its fees by 25% to reduce the burden of the levy. Local ownership is 23.7% and MTN has committed to achieve localisation of 30%, so further dilution in the business is coming.
  • Investment holding company Sabvest Capital has released a trading statement for the six months to June 2022. The most appropriate metric in my view is net asset value (NAV) per share, which has increased by between 20.1% and 27.4%. The proposed dividend is also showing juicy growth, up 50% to 30 cents per share. The share price closed 5.6% higher at R75, a discount to the midpoint of the guided NAV of 26%. This is low by investment holding company standards, indicating the love that the market has for this company.
  • JSE Limited has released interim results for the six months to June 2022. Yes, the JSE is listed on the JSE. You are not dreaming. Revenue increased by 11% and expenses only increased by 3%, so this was a strong period in which EBITDA jumped by 20% and EBITDA margin expanded by 300 basis points to 45%. HEPS was 29% higher at 542.7 cents. R534 million was generated in cash from operations and only R51 million was spent on capital expenditure. The group has market share of 99.7% of equity market value traded, which shows how tough it has been for competitors to make any progress.
  • Textainer has released its results for the quarter ended June 2022. Income from operations is ticking over nicely, up 11.7% year-on-year and 7% vs. the immediately preceding quarter. The fleet has grown and utilisation has dropped by only 10 basis points, so fleet size is a driver of growth in earnings. The company has used share buybacks effectively and has authorised a further $100 million for the buyback programme. A dividend of $0.25 per share has been declared. The share price is down 3.8% this year.
  • Capital & Counties Properties released results for the six months to June 2022. Comments like “high occupancy levels and excellent demand” are just great to see in this sector, admittedly with reference to property in London’s West End. The company is in the process of merging with Shaftesbury to create Shaftesbury Capital, a mixed-use REIT with a portfolio of around 670 properties across the West End. In the meantime, it’s worth noting that Capital & Counties’ portfolio increased in value by 4.5% in the past six months. Footfall has trended towards pre-Covid levels and customer sales are higher than in 2019. Due to movements in the Shaftesbury share price, the total return per share is actually -1.2% for the period.
  • HomeChoice International released a trading statement for the six months to June 2022. HEPS is expected to be at least 20% higher than in the comparable period. The share price didn’t move because there is almost no trade in this stock.

Operational updates

  • I don’t have a section called “mineral reserve updates” so this will just have to go here. Alphamin has announced updated mineral resource and mineral reserve estimates for the Mpama North Mine, with the updated life of mine schedule showing replacement of tin that has been depleted over the past 2.5 years and slightly higher contained tin inventory vs. the previous estimate. This is the result of additional exploration drilling since the last estimate was prepared in 2019.

Share buybacks and dividends

  • Naspers and Prosus are busy with a repurchase programme and the numbers are enormous. Last week, Naspers repurchased shares worth R1.64 billion and Prosus repurchased shares worth €218 million.

Notable shuffling of (expensive) chairs

  • Wesizwe Platinum has appointed Mr Zou Long as the CEO of the company. He has extensive experience in mining in Africa.

Director dealings

  • Astoria Investments announced that an entity related to two non-executive directors has acquired shares in the company worth nearly R88.5k. The share price closed 40% higher on the day in what seems like a classic case of finger trouble on the JSE. Sometimes, orders are put in at the wrong price!
  • A director of Kaap Agri has bought shares in the company worth nearly R33k.
  • A director of enX Group has bought shares in the company worth R218k.

Unusual things

  • None!

If you enjoyed Ghost Bites, then make sure you’re on the mailing list for a daily dose of market insights in Ghost Mail. It’s free! SIGN UP HERE >>>

Telkom: what is MTN seeing here?

Telkom has had the difficult task of evolving from a technological dinosaur into a data-focused telecoms business. It hasn’t been easy, with the group on a treadmill of declining legacy revenue and pressure on cash flows.

Telkom has released a trading update for the quarter ended June 2022. The numbers aren’t pretty I’m afraid, with a drop in revenue of 3.2% and a nasty knock to group EBITDA of 15.2%. There is a 320 basis points contraction in EBITDA margin to 22.7%, which is what happens when your staff get an increase of 6% and your revenue shrinks.

Spectrum and fibre. There are the juicy bits that I think MTN is after at Telkom, with the yellow giant recently announcing that it is contemplating a buyout offer for Telkom. If nothing else, it inspired my most popular tweet since I became a ghost:

The core product offering of a telecoms business is incredibly boring. Phone calls and mobile data usage are so 2010. Don’t even get me started on SMS, which was last relevant when people listened to Backstreet Boys. The acronym should now be Spam Messaging Service instead.

Speaking of has-beens, fixed legacy voice revenue fell by 19.9%, mainly in the Enterprise and Small to Medium Business segments. There are still grannies out there with home phones but almost everyone else has given up.

Keen to move into new growth areas that preferably offer better margins, telecoms companies have pushed into fibre packages and even financial services. In emerging markets in Africa, using smartphones to distribute products makes a world of sense.

In the US, telecoms companies have chosen to push the streaming angle instead, partnering with content providers in an attempt to push data products. We explored this interesting point when we covered AT&T in Magic Markets Premium.

Telkom’s mobile business is also picking up, though I’m not convinced that the Competition Commission will be thrilled about this potentially rolling into MTN. Active mobile subscribers increased 7.8% year-on-year to 17.3 million, with an ARPU (average revenue per user) of R88.53. The vast majority (14.5 million) are prepaid subscribers, which is why the ARPU is much lower. A contract subscriber has an ARPU of R208.50 and a prepaid subscriber has an ARPU of R64.77.

Mobile data traffic increased by 12.4%, which means that (unsurprisingly) each subscriber is using more data than before. There has been a 2% increase in broadband subscribers to 10.7 million. The problem is that pricing decreased by 14.8% as data becomes cheaper every year, so overall mobile data revenue actually fell year-on-year.

In the fibre business (Openserve), which is what I think MTN wants above all else, fixed traffic increased by 18.9% and the number of homes passed with fibre grew by 45.3% to over 890,000. The connectivity rate is 46.6%, which is the number of homes actually connected (414,847) vs. the number of homes who had their pavements destroyed to lay fibre. The number of connected homes grew by 35.2% which is lower than the growth rate in homes passed by fibre, so the connectivity rate has dropped. Still, Telkom says this is the highest rate in the market.

Openserve’s fibre revenue increased by 6.5%, with broadband services growing to over 612,000 and offsetting the copper access decline. Fixed voice revenue fell by 24%, so the net impact for the business is a revenue decline of 3.9%. EBITDA margin was also hit by increased costs, coming in at 29.9% for the quarter.

Notably, Openserve has been split into a separate legal entity. This is usually a precursor to a transaction for that part of the business. I suspect that MTN is ready to negotiate with the Competition Commission on the basis of getting Openserve and leaving behind the mobile business if needed.

Moving on to the masts and towers, Swiftnet now has 3,935 towers and achieved revenue this quarter of R322 million, ever so slightly lower than R325 million in the comparable period. The pipeline is over 2,000 sites and 393 already have approved building plans. The EBITDA margin is 71.4%, up from 67.2% in the prior period on a normalised basis. This business was earmarked for a separate listing but market conditions aren’t favourable.

The BCX IT business had a mixed performance across its business units, with an overall decline in revenue of 3.7%. An improved supply chain outlook for the remainder of this year is a positive sign. The really good news is that EBITDA has improved by 15.6% because of a focus on efficiencies. This is impressive vs. the revenue result.

One of the other good news stories is a reduction in capital expenditure by 35.2% because of front-loaded expenditure in the past two years.

To end off, here’s a chart showing the share prices of the three telecoms players over the past year. Even after the recent decline, MTN has been the star of the show, with the Vodacom share price even more boring than fixed line voice calls:

Do you hold a position in this sector? Let us know in the comments!

Massmart proves that bad can get worse

Massmart’s release of a trading statement inspired me to remind Ghost Mail readers that no matter how bad things seem, they can usually get worse. Even Charles Leclerc is learning this the hard way at Ferrari.

Recently, I wrote an article on how defensive stocks often aren’t as defensive as people think. The issue lies in margin mix, with the “defensive” product categories typically achieving the lowest margins. If you can get it right at scale, it is a far better business to sell consumer electronics than to sell bread. You make more money selling clothes than selling baked beans.

When the economy turns against you though, there are more beans and loaves of bread in the trolleys than TVs and new hoodies.

Massmart’s parent company Walmart has had a couple of tough quarters and this was a strong leading indicator of the troubles at Massmart. With the release of a sales update and trading statement for the 26 weeks ended June 2022, we now know that things are just getting worse at Massmart.

Last chance saloon?

For years, Massmart was a mixed bag of great businesses (Makro and Builders) and truly awful businesses (Game and the entire cash and carry operation). With a silo mentality and lack of cohesion at the centre, there was much head scratching by the market about why this issue couldn’t be resolved.

Eventually, Walmart stopped scratching its head and decided to take action, parachuting in Mitchell Slape to come and work some magic on the group. Although it may look from the outside like a total flop, one has to remember the impact of Covid over this period. It really hasn’t been an easy task to fix this thing.

Slape has tried to create more centralised structures, cut costs and outsource certain support functions of the business. Walmart gave the group critical financial assistance during Covid, without which I think things may have gone the same way as Edcon.

Massmart agreed to sell some of its messiest businesses to Shoprite, for reasons that remain a mystery to me from a Shoprite perspective. The Brackenfell Bruisers should’ve just waited for Massmart to shut the stores and give up, rather than actually paying money for the space. The deal is still stuck at the Competition Commission.

So, there has been action. There’s also been share price action, primarily towards the bottom right of the page. The share price is down 45% this year alone. This has been a disastrous acquisition for Walmart.

The most important question is this: how much more patience does Walmart have? We are way past a seriously high pain threshold for the Americans.

Looking into the result

Sales from continuing operations (excluding the horror shows of Cambridge, Rhino and Massfresh) increased by 1.9% over the prior year. Comparable store sales increased by 4.3%. If you really try hard with your filters in Excel and remove the non-core, discontinued store base in South Africa (thereby leaving out some of the worst Game stores too), the comparable sales growth is 5.1%.

Yippee. With internal inflation of 4.8%, that means volumes increased by 0.3%. Pop open the champagne for this epic growth story.

Speaking of champagne, liquor sales grew by 21.3%. Massmart highlights a recovery in the Hospitality, Restaurant and Catering customer base. Perhaps the company executives are just drowning their sorrows.

General Merchandise, a key category that drives margins, experienced a decline in sales of 1.4%. This is where the problems start.

Discontinued operations is where they get far worse. I’m not sure there will be much left for Shoprite to buy, with sales down 19.7% and like-for-like sales down 17.2%. The civil unrest in July 2021 is blamed for this result, with stores remaining closed and products not re-introduced into stores. Whilst I have no doubt that there has been an impact, I also think that’s a convenient excuse for a part of the business that has destroyed shareholder value for years. On the plus side, this side of the business is shrinking so quickly that at some point it will be too small for the Competition Commission to even care anymore.

There are some once-offs in the numbers, like R184 million to get out of the lease for the Riverhorse Distribution Centre that was destroyed in the unrest. Massmart has received another R270 million in business interruption insurance, taking the total recovery to R370 million. The company hopes to get the remaining payment before the end of the year.

At group level, the headline loss is expected to be between -R910.3 million and -R974.9 million. For continuing operations, the headline loss is expected to be between -R885.7 million and -R921.5 million. This is perhaps the scariest point of all: the gap between total loss and continuing loss really isn’t that big.

On a per share basis and just looking at continuing operations, the headline loss is about 2.5x worse than in the comparable period. Ouch.

I made good money on Massmart in 2020 at a time when the share price had dropped too far. I took profit and got out the way, which was definitely the right decision.

Ghost Global (Apple | Procter & Gamble | Renault | Amazon)

Even Apple’s earnings fell

Apple has released results for its third quarter for FY 2022. The company reported only a 2% increase in revenue, bringing it to $83 billion and setting third quarter records in North America, South America, Europe and the Asia Pacific region.

The company is pleased with this achievement in the face of external challenges such as supply constraints, foreign exchange headwinds and the halt of operations in Russia.

iPhone revenue set a record of $40.7 billion, rising 3%. Although Mac revenue dropped 10% to $7.4 billion, the company is confident that its investment in the product is fueling growth in Apple’s installed customer base, as almost half of customers purchasing a Mac this quarter were new users. iPad revenue dropped 2% to $7.2 billion and revenue from Wearables, Home, and Accessories was down 8% to just over $8 billion. The company blamed these decreases on macroeconomic conditions. Service revenue was up 12% to reach $19.6 billion, setting revenue records in Music, Cloud Services, Apple Care, and Payment Services. Essentially, iPhone and services carried the team as the two largest segments.

Product gross margin fell by 150 basis points to 34.5%. Services gross margin improved by 170 basis points to 71.5%. Overall, gross margin was flat year-on-year at 43.3%, an impressive performance that helped protect a modest improvement in gross margin.

By the time we reach the bottom of the income statement, we find that diluted earnings per share fell by 7.7% year-on-year, as the inflationary pressures on operating expenses hurt the business.

Still, the company is optimistic about the strength of its ecosystem, citing all-time highs in all major product categories throughout geographic segments. There are now over 860 million paid subscriptions across Apple’s platform. The company has placed emphasis on improving service offerings such as Apple Music, Apple TV+ and Apple Arcade. Apple is also optimistic about its presence in the enterprise market, highlighting Bank of America providing iPhones to all its financial advisors and IT company, Wipro, investing in MacBook Air for its new graduates.

Pampering shareholders

The Procter & Gamble Company (P&G), owners of brands such as Pampers, Ariel laundry products, Oral-B and Head and Shoulders, has released results for its 2022 financial year.

Organic sales (excluding forex impacts and acquisitions / disposals) increased by 7% for the full year, including a 2% increase in volume. In the final quarter, volumes were down 1% thanks to lockdowns in China and the impact of Russia and pricing was 8% higher as inflation came through. Net sales were up 3% in the fourth quarter and 5% for the full year.

Organic sales in the US were up 6% (and 24% over three years), while in European Focus markets they were up 3%. Excluding Russia, organic sales in European Focus markets grew by 7%. Organic sales in the Greater China region were down 11%, largely due to Covid-19 lockdowns. This is obviously a temporary issue.

Full year core earnings per share (EPS) increased by 3% despite the pressures from commodities, freight and foreign exchange. Looking at online channels, eCommerce sales increased by 11% and now represent 14% of total revenue in P&G’s biggest market, the US.

P&G anticipates volatility in the coming financial year from foreign exchange rates, freight costs, materials, fuel, energy and wage inflation. Still, positive earnings growth is more than some of the world’s most exciting companies can say.

“Renaulution”: silly name, good results

Groupe Renault, the French automobile manufacturer, has released results for the first half of its 2022 financial year. Despite a reduction in unit sales of 11.9% (around 136,000 units), net debt has fallen by €1.2 billion to €426 million. This was achieved through a strong increase in operating margin from 2.1% to 4.7%, driving a period in which cash generation reached a 10-year high.

The company feels confident about the success of its “Renaulution,” a strategy which focuses on three levels of transformation.

The first is the company’s go-to-market approach which puts value above volume. Renault has been focusing on improving its current product mix, such as its hybrid and electric cars.  Over the last 18 months, the company has completely replaced diesel with hybrid cars.

The second level is described as a “product offensive enabling commercial successes.” This includes the production of new offerings such as the Mégane E-TECH which was placed second in the Car of the Year competition.

The third level is the renewal of the company’s competitiveness. The company has also found success in its Arkana and Dacia models and has high expectations for its new Austral, C-SUV. On the third level, Renault has lowered its break-even point by over 40% and is confident that it will weather the energy-shortage storm due to low reliance on Russian gas.

The company has upgraded its outlook for the full financial year, something that investors always love seeing.

Amazon takes a major knock from its non-core assets

Amazon has announced its Q2 results for its 2022 financial year, with a spectacular net loss of $2 billion vs. a net profit of $7.8 billion a year ago. In case you’re wondering how this is possible, a valuation loss of $3.9 billion on the stake in Rivian Automotive in this quarter might give you a clue.

On a trailing twelve months basis, worldwide net sales increased by 10%. They were up 7% in this quarter vs. the comparable quarter. Operating income was crushed by rising inflation, which is leading to higher fuel, trucking, air and ocean shipping rates. Operating margin was just 2.7% in this quarter vs. 6.8% in the comparable period.

The company has emphasised its efforts to make its Prime membership more valuable through innovations such as airing the premiere of the new Lord of the Rings film as well as obtaining exclusive rights to air NFL Thursday Night Football games. Amazon is also pleased with its improvement in customer experience, citing improved delivery speed and in-stock inventory levels.

Numbers are what really count though, with a 57% decrease in operating income. Because markets are volatile and ridiculous, the share price is up nearly 20% in the past month.

Looking at Amazon Web Services, the part of the group that makes the most money, revenue was up 33% in this quarter and operating income grew 28%. There was some margin compression even in this area of the business, which is part of what hurt the broader story.

Amazon expects sales growth of between 13% and 17% in the next quarter, despite the preceding three quarters of single digit sales growth. The company also had its 2-day Prime Day event in July this year instead of June as in 2021, which is expected to have a positive impact on its Q3 results.

For just R99/month or R990/year, you can have access to institutional-quality research that is guaranteed to expand your investment knowledge. Visit the Magic Markets website to subscribe.

Ghost Bites Vol 60 (22)

Corporate finance corner (M&A / capital raises)

  • Rebosis Property Fund is up the proverbial creek without a paddle, though the company is trying hard to make one while battling the stream. In a fight in the wilderness that would make Bear Grylls nervous, the company has committed to bringing a strategy for the balance sheet to shareholders by no later than 15th August. The share price fell sharply this year after the sale of a huge property portfolio to an entity linked to Vunani fell through. Over 5 years, the share price is down 98.7%. Sometimes, it’s better to spend your money on a few Steers burgers rather than putting it in the market.
  • The Conduit Capital share price lost half its value yesterday and there was decent volume to go with it (by small cap standards), so this wasn’t someone pressing the wrong button. The group is trying to recapitalise its insurance business and is in negotiations with at least two potential investors. The Prudential Authority has run out of patience though, with an application to the High Court to place Constantia Insurance Company (one of the subsidiaries) under provisional curatorship. This means that no new business can be written until the curator is satisfied that doing so won’t impact the regulatory capital of the entity. Management expects the process to be concluded shortly and the restriction to be lifted. Importantly, this doesn’t impact the business of Constantia Life and Health Assurance or Constantia Life Limited. The announcement also confirms that Constantia Insurance has sufficient resources to meet policyholder claims.
  • Ascendis Health has released further details of its rights offer worth R101.5 million. The pricing is 71 cents per share, which is the 30-day volume weighted average price (VWAP). It’s unusual to see a rights offer at the VWAP rather than at a discount. As the offer is fully underwritten by Calibre Investment Holdings (in return for a 2% fee – just over R2 million), Ascendis doesn’t need to entice existing shareholders with a price below the market price. The entire process will be wrapped up this month, as JSE timetables for rights offers are quite tight. This makes sense because companies need to be able to move fairly quickly when raising capital.
  • Kaap Agri has finalised the implementation of the transaction to acquire PEG Retail Holdings in its fuel business. The effective date was 1 July 2022. The operations have “exceeded its performance expectations” and three months of earnings will be included in results for the year ended September 2022.
  • Blue Label Telecoms has announced that the recapitalisation of Cell C has experienced some delays in the finalisation of documentation. The transaction is now expected to close towards the end of August.
  • Tradehold is in the process of selling its stake in Moorgarth Holdings for £102.5 million and has now released the circular for the transaction. Shareholders and interested parties can find it here.

Financial updates

  • Thungela Resources has released a trading statement for the six months ended June 2022. The share price traded above R300 intraday before settling down to close 0.25% higher at R291.60. This is a company that traded at around R22 when it listed back in June 2021! For the six-month period, headline earnings per share (HEPS) will be between R66.85 and R67.45, which makes the initial listing price even more ridiculous. There’s no point in looking at this number vs. the comparable period, as the group was being restructured at that time and the operations weren’t in there, so there were practically no earnings. This result was driven by strong benchmark coal prices for thermal coal, with negative impacts from inflationary pressures on costs and fair value losses on the “price risk management programme” – a fancy term for hedging the price of coal.
  • MTN has released a trading statement for the six months ended June 2022. HEPS has increased by between 40% and 50%, coming in at 542 – 581 cents for the interim period. The share price only closed 2.3% higher at R142.26, so the market was clearly expecting something along these lines. I’m very tempted to add MTN at these levels, as the group is growing strongly and it wasn’t long ago that we saw it trading at over R200 (admittedly an overcooked level). The concern in the market remains around availability of foreign currency in Nigeria, as MTN has historically struggled to upstream cash to South Africa. Overall, I’ve become bullish on the growth story and MTN’s role in African markets where the smartphone becomes a critical distribution tool for other financial products. I didn’t always believe in that story but now I do.
  • Liberty Two Degrees has released results for the six months ended June 2022. The most important metrics look promising, with retail turnover up 25.1% and portfolio footcount up 28%. Retail occupancy has increased to 97.2%. Negative reversions are still an issue though, with portfolio reversions at -16.3% in this period. That’s better than -25.5% in the comparable period. Remember, reversions only apply to leases that have expired. Escalations on ongoing leases were 6.8%, a healthy percentage and a reminder of why property is considered an inflation hedge. The improvements in hotel occupancies are notable: Sandton Sun occupancy was 71.5% vs. 39.8% in the comparable period and Garden Court was 40.7% vs. 12.8%. Liberty Two Degrees has a strong balance sheet with a loan-to-value of 24.64%. This supports an increase in the distribution per share of 10.7% to 17.48 cents per share. Despite the positive underlying story in retail property, the net asset value per share decreased slightly by 1.18% based on the value of the portfolio. This excerpt demonstrates that things are still tricky out there:

“The recovery in our office exposure remains muted whilst the continued double digit increases in municipal and utility costs, coupled with increased periods of loadshedding and a weak consumer environment facing increased inflationary pressure, remains a catalyst for downside pressure on the portfolio’s performance.”

Liberty Two Degrees interim results
  • aReit Prop Limited is, well, a REIT. The recently-listed company initially launched without a working website (now fixed) and has now released a financial announcement that compares the six months ended June 2022 to the three months ended March 2022, disclosing the percentage difference. Except, you know, the March numbers are inside the June numbers because they are overlapping periods of different lengths. It just hurts my head. Ignoring this nonsense, the important news is that the company has declared 100% of its distributable profits over the past six months in dividends. The total distribution per share over six months is 20.34 cents and the share price is R7.30, so the annualised yield is 5.6%. The net asset value (NAV) per share is 935.2 cents.

Operational updates

  • Southern Palladium has released a quarterly update for the three months ended June 2022. They’ve completed a Total Magnetic Field (TMF) spectrometry survey, which sounds like something out of an X-Men movie. Moving on to things that I do understand, the company raised $19 million in an oversubscribed IPO process in April as a precursor to the listing in June. The key asset is the Bengwenyama PGM Project, in which it holds a 70% stake. There are various activities underway, including preparation for the drilling programme that will commence in September. The budget for the two phases of drilling work is $11.5 million in total. Other technical work is expected to cost $1.68 million and a further $3.9 million has been set aside for corporate and other related costs. To give an idea of how expensive it is for a newcomer to the market to raise funds, the costs of the IPO were $1.7 million.

Share buybacks and dividends

  • enX Group has sold two businesses in the past 14 months (Impact Fork Trucks and EIE Group), realising proceeds of R1.34 billion along the way. After various other uses for the cash, there’s enough left in the kitty for a special distribution of R1.50 per share. The share price closed 11.3% higher at R6.90.

Notable shuffling of (expensive) chairs

  • The chairs stayed where they were today!

Director dealings

  • Spear REIT CEO Quintin Rossi is still buying shares in the company for his kids. We have to assume he believes in the company’s prospects then, unless they’ve been naughty lately and he’s trying to punish them. Somehow, I think it’s the former.
  • A few directors and prescribed officers (including the CFO and Company Secretary) of Alexander Forbes are happily selling their shares in the partial offer being made by Prudential Financial.

Unusual things

  • Afristrat and Primeserv are still in the JSE naughty corner, as both companies have missed the deadline for annual report submission and are facing possible listing suspensions unless they comply before the end of September.

If you enjoyed Ghost Bites, then make sure you’re on the mailing list for a daily dose of market insights in Ghost Mail. It’s free! SIGN UP HERE >>>

Africa – the final frontier (part 2)

In part 1 of this series, Chris Gilmour focused on the positives and negatives of the continent that has hurt many corporates in their pursuit of growth. In part 2, Gilmour gives us a history lesson on the continent, an overview of foreign direct investment and his views on the risks of Africa’s relationship with China

Globalisation really took off properly when the US started getting in on the act in the late 1980s / early 1990s. It coincided with the eradication of communism, a prerequisite for globalisation. Until then, the world was effectively divided in two from an economic perspective – on one hand the US and its allies with Pax Americana and on the other the Soviet bloc and its surrogates.

A quick history lesson

The US had a certain influence in Africa, though it tended to be done covertly. So, for example, it backed apartheid South Africa until the late 1980s when it eventually promulgated the Comprehensive Anti-Apartheid Act. But it also installed its own, usually despotic surrogates in countries like Zaire (now the DRC) with Mobutu Sese Seko, having previously connived with Belgium to depose the legitimately-elected Patrice Lumumba.

The Soviets were far more open about their alliances, though they often used other allies to do their dirty work in Africa. They used East Germans and Cubans in Angola but were far more direct in their support of Samora Machel in Mozambique. The Soviet Union was interested in Africa from the perspective of furthering the aims of international socialism/communism. They certainly weren’t interested in African metals and minerals, as they had plenty back home. However, they were very good at depleting the fishing beds off the Mozambican coast for example.  

The former colonial powers – Britain, Belgium, France, Portugal and Germany – had lost their influence long before the advent of globalisation. The Belgians and the French left their colonies in a pretty sorry state, even uprooting the telegraph poles when they left and taking them back home. Political structures were virtually non-existent and “controlled anarchy” prevailed in most of their ex-colonies.

Portugal’s colonies – Angola and Mozambique – were left to their own devices in the mid-1970s after the fall of Salazar and Caetano in Portugal. Both countries suffered badly in vicious civil wars.

Germany had two colonies – South West Africa (now Namibia) and Tanganyika (now Tanzania) – but had them confiscated by the League of Nations post World War 1. It is interesting to note the very strong German influence in Namibia, even today.

Only Britain left its former colonies – Northern and Southern Rhodesia (now Zambia and Zimbabwe respectively), Kenya, Botswana, Lesotho, Ghana and Nigeria mainly – in reasonable shape. It installed a decent legal, education and political structure in these countries and made dignified exits from all of them, starting with Ghana in 1957. Of course, African nationalists would argue that this wasn’t done for any philanthropic reasons but merely to ensure that British ex-pats had a good life in the ”colonies”.

The joker in the pack, not just today but since the late 1970s, has been the arrival of the Chinese in Africa. China has been active on the continent in many countries but has vastly increased its presence in recent times. Its insatiable demand for commodities is the main reason for its presence. But whereas Chinese involvement was part of fraternal socialism in the 1960s and 70s, these days the Chinese are looking for and receiving a tangible return on their investments in Africa. There’s no such thing as a free lunch any more. The Belt and Road initiative spawned by current Chinese leader Xi Jinping back in 2014 has had limited success so far in Africa.

The Russians have long gone, as have the Cubans and the East Germans. American influence has all but disappeared as a new order has flexed its muscle in South Africa. But China’s influence is growing dramatically.

The jokers in the pack

Chinese goods are found all over the continent, as are Chinese companies. The Chinese government has only been too willing to advance multi-billion dollar loans to various African governments, with few political but many economic ties attached. So, for example, China is only too happy to construct airports and other essential infrastructure in countries such as Zambia. When the Zambians start crying because they can’t pay, the Chinese just keep the assets.

China sees Africa as being a large quarry and has established good relationships with governments and other institutions in order to be able to continue extracting metals and minerals from the earth.

The other joker in the pack, of course, is South Africa. It is the powerhouse of the continent, providing about 30% of the continent’s GDP. Its stock exchange is about 3 times the size of the rest of the continent’s stock exchanges combined. Eskom, the state-owned electricity utility, produces about 60% of the continent’s electricity, although that differential is rapidly being eroded as Eskom suffers from a continuing inability to supply continuous power.

And yet, when it comes to decision-making at bodies like the African Union (AU), South Africa’s voice is hardly heard or heeded. The main reason for this is that the rest of Africa still views South Africa with a degree of suspicion. Many countries still see it as being largely a white-owned economy (which it undoubtedly is) and thus lacking in “African” credentials.

Foreign direct investment (or lack thereof)

And when it comes to inward foreign investment, South Africa is far behind the curve compared with many other African countries. An argument can be made that Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment (B-BBEE) is a deterrent to foreign direct investment (FDI), as it creates a complex regulatory environment and the need for in-country shareholders, a concept that many multinational companies aren’t comfortable with. Although the legislation has tried to address this issue, the facts remain that South Africa has attracted lots of portfolio investment but little in the way of true “bricks and mortar” FDI. Portfolio investment is highly capricious and the taps can be turned off at any time.

Countries like Angola have attracted lots of genuine FDI in recent years, mainly directed towards the oil industry. Until recently, Angola received huge amounts of money from China but with the change of government about five years ago, that has all changed and relations have soured. The number of Chinese in Angola has plummeted from 300 000 to about 50 000. And Mozambique had also attracted a lot of FDI, ironically from South African companies looking for investment opportunities. However, the appetite for Mozambican investment is waning with the emergence of ISIS forces in that country.

It’s interesting to note the relative lack of success that many multinationals have had in South Africa. Take McDonald’s for example. It can usually be used as a proxy for globalisation success in most parts of the world. For example, travelling around the lovely old town of Krakow in Poland in an open horse carriage, one turns the corner and is confronted by the dreadful golden arches of McDonald’s. It shows the extent to which globalisation has commoditised so many facets of life in such a remarkably short space of time.

But in SA, the number of McDonald’s restaurants is nowhere near the size of the local Famous Brands’ outlets or even KFC for that matter. Because of apartheid, local firms weren’t able to invest offshore and so the country embarked upon a widespread program of inward industrialisation. Intuitively, this should have been an inefficient process but in fact the opposite was true. When apartheid was dismantled, these companies were able to invest offshore and were remarkably successful.

And companies like McDonald’s were confronted by fast food companies that beat them at their own game. Not only were they able to compete on a level playing field but their products had taste, unlike McDonald’s commoditised merchandise.

In fact, all over Africa, one struggles to find examples of US globalisation. Financial institutions tend to be either British or South African. Brewers are French (Castel), Dutch (Heineken) or Brazilian/Belgian (AB Inbev). Construction companies are either South African or Chinese, while steel makers are Indian. A few US multinationals like 3M and Halliburton exist in Africa but their focus is once again on oil, as in Angola for example.

Can the shackles be broken?

But what has been the impact on the lives on ordinary Africans? Generally speaking it’s improving, albeit from an exceptionally low base. The Gini coefficient of most African countries (which measures the disparity between rich and poor) is not that great.  However, in South Africa, it is one of the highest in the world. This is because the impact of high economic growth hasn’t really been felt by the great mass of the population and unemployment remains stubbornly high. Like eastern Europe, China and India, South Africa has more than its fair share of “oligarchs” – people who have benefited disproportionately from the effects of globalisation.

Corruption on the continent of Africa is rife, probably more so than in any other continent. It is this factor, combined with an archaic obedience to giving fealty to authority, that has hobbled the continent, or as Robert Guest puts it so eloquently “the Shackled Continent”.

Africa will only be able to break free from these shackles by having decades of sustained and robust economic growth. Hopefully it will be allowed to, but there is the omnipresent threat that the Chinese, who have demonstrated such a blatant disregard for human rights in their own country, will be tempted to do the same in Africa.

The danger is that the Chinese will colonise Africa economically, using bribery and corruption to get despotic governments on side, in an attempt to ensure supplies of commodities to fuel its insatiable economic boom. In other words, Africa may become the fodder for China’s imperialistic ambitions.

One possible ray of light is the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA). Modelled very loosely on the European Free Trade Association (EFTA), this has the potential to liberate Africa from a lot of the bureaucratic nonsense that currently pervades the continent. Offering the four freedoms of capital, people, goods and services, the implementation of AfCFTA should help to alleviate poverty and free up the continent at long last. It has only really been in existence since 2019 and the coronavirus pandemic didn’t help its genesis. Regional organisations such as ECOWAS have been relatively impotent as far as improving bureaucracy are concerned and the African Union (AU) is a talk-shop. The Chinese recently built new headquarters for the AU in Addis Ababa at a cost of $200 million and the new ECOWAS head office in Abuja for $31 million, so the precedents are not good.

Hopefully, AfCTFA will manage to steer clear of accepting Chinese largesse and be the exception that proves the rule.

This article represents the views and opinions of Chris Gilmour as an independent writer.

Ghost Bites Vol 59 (22)

Corporate finance corner (M&A / capital raises)

  • Vukile Property Fund is acquiring the Pan Africa Shopping Centre in Wynberg, Johannesburg. The centre serves the market in Alexandra township and has Boxer as its anchor tenant among the 60 shops in the mall. The fund’s focus in South Africa is on mid- to low-LSM shopping centres, so this mall fits that description. The acquisition will be funded by existing resources, so this won’t impact the loan-to-value ratio of 43%. A phase 2 extension of the shopping centre is being planned and demand from new tenants is strong. The sellers include Atterbury Property, which holds a stake of nearly 51% in the property. The structure of the deal is interesting, with Vukile acquiring phase 1 for nearly R415 million now and phase 2 for just over R254 million only once completed, which is envisaged to be the case in April 2024. The price for phase 2 has been estimated based on a capitalisation rate of 9.25%, which means taking the annual net operating income (NOI) and dividing it by 9.25%. The price for phase 2 may differ based on actual NOI once the development is complete. This is a category 2 transaction under JSE rules, which means shareholders are made aware of the detailed terms but aren’t asked to vote on the deal.
  • DRA Global has agreed to sell its Australian maintenance and construction business (G&S) for $8 million. This unfortunately leads to an impairment (primarily to goodwill) of between $17 million and $20 million in DRA’s income statement. The company has also withdrawn its underlying EBIT guidance for FY22. G&S is currently loss-making and contributed 20% of group revenue for the year ended December 2021.
  • Orion Minerals is trying its best to raise capital to develop its portfolio of base metal assets in the Northern Cape. As market conditions have deteriorated this year, major investors asked for more time to make a final decision. In the world of dealmaking, “more time” is always the enemy as it increases the chances of cold feet. The company has also invited eligible shareholders to apply for parcels of shares with a minimum value of $2,000 and a maximum value of $30,000. Orion has announced an extension of the deadline for that capital raise by one week to 12 August. If you want more information, refer to the company booklet here.
  • Heriot REIT is in the process of making an offer to the shareholders of Safari Investments. The company has been engaging with Safari and the Takeover Regulation Panel (TRP) regarding the commercial terms of the offer. The TRP has given Heriot as extension until 12 August to post the offer circular.
  • Emira is in the process of making an offer for 100% of the shares in Transcend Residential Property Fund. The Takeover Regulation Panel (TRP) has granted an extension for the distribution of the circular until 6 September.
  • Capital & Counties Properties and Shaftesbury are in the process of merging and both companies have now achieved shareholder approval for the transaction. The parties hope to complete the deal by the end of 2022.
  • Kibo Energy received £1 million worth of shares from Mast Energy Developments (MED) in partial settlement of a shareholder loan owing to a subsidiary of Kibo. After this share issue, the remaining loan is £1.27 million. The shares were issued at the 5-day VWAP plus a premium of 20%. After receiving these shares, Kibo owns 61.27% in MED.

Financial updates

  • Industrials REIT has released a trading update for the first quarter of the 2023 financial year. This covers the three months to June 2022. The fund is focused on UK multi-let industrial properties, which are still enjoying strong levels of demand. Demand for space continues to exceed supply in the UK, which has supported a 27% average increase in rent on new lettings and renewals this quarter. The fund has a low loan-to-value ratio of 26%, which means there is plenty of flexibility on the balance sheet to take advantage of opportunities. Looking more closely at the leases themselves, the average lease signed during the quarter was for 4.6 years and 62% of completed leases were contracted through the fund’s short-form digital “Smart Leases” – up from 53% in the previous quarter. 76% of leases included at least a 3% annual uplift in rent throughout the term of the lease. Portfolio occupancy is stable at 93.7%. The fund also highlights its asset management track record at Hillfoot Industrial Estate, with various improvements driving an anticipated yield on cost of over 26%. The market is cautious though and Industrials REIT is also playing it safer, with only two acquisitions in this quarter and one recent disposal after the quarter. The share price is down 23% this year but has jumped 10.6% in the past month.
  • EOH is trading below R5 per share, so I’m very happy that I got out of the way in the mid-R7s. The problem is that the company couldn’t sell its assets quickly enough to deal with the debt, so too much of the value ended up going to interest rather than capital. The company has now released a pre-close update for the financial year ending 31 July 2022. After the disposals of Sybrin and Information Services Group, EOH has R1.33 billion in gross debt (a R500 million bullet facility maturing in April 2025 and a R832 million bridge facility maturing in April 2023) and R540 million in gross cash. With interest rates on the rise, this is still a major problem. The proceeds from the sale of Network Solutions and Hymax SA will reduce the debt by another R100 million. On top of this, there are still two legacy issues – one relating to the Department of Water and Sanitation and the other with SARS in relation to a PAYE dispute. At group level, gross profit and EBITDA margins are expected to be consistent with the first half of the year. Looking deeper, NEXTEC had a tough second half of the year in its Infrastructure Solutions Business, with a significant negative impact from supply chain issues and delays in large projects, mainly in the public sector. The iOCO segment had a decent second half of the year in line with the first half, which isn’t ideal as the second half is normally stronger than the first half. Again, the hardware business was hit by supply chain disruptions. Despite best efforts with the existing businesses and a plan to save R60 million in costs, the reality is that EOH is going to need to do something more to fix the balance sheet. Here’s a clue of what might be coming:

“The board and management continue to assess the group’s capital raising options and expect to announce its capital raising plans alongside the release of its year end results.”

EOH pre-close update, 29 July
  • Astoria Investments has released quarterly results for the three months to June 2022. Over the past 12 months, the net asset value (NAV) per share increased from $61.49 to $69.23, an increase of 12.6%. Because of the sharp change in the exchange rate, the rand increase over that period is 28.5% and the latest NAV per share is R11.31. The share price closed 6.5% higher on the day of results at R5.70, an approximately 50% discount to NAV that is typical of investment holding companies. Investments in the portfolio include Outdoor Investment Holdings (owner of Safari & Outdoor and related businesses), RECM and Calibre preference shares (giving exposure to Goldrush), Trans Hex Group (a diamonds business), Leatt Corporation (protective equipment for motorsport and leisure activities), ISA Carstens (a tertiary education business focused on health and wellness) and Vehicle Care Group (financial and related services in the used vehicle trade). The Afrimat holding was sold to fund the purchase of shares in Leatt Corporation. Astoria has also withdrawn its cautionary announcement and given details of an investment of $5.5 million for 25.1% of International Mining and Dredging Holdings, a group involved in marine and offshore mining and exploration, including vessels focused on marine diamond mining off the coast of South Africa and Namibia. There are important synergies here with the Trans Hex business.
  • MTN Nigeria, a critical investment in the MTN Group, released results for the six months to June 2022. Mobile subscribers increased by 7.6%, active data users increased by 13.2% and fintech subscribers skyrocketed 87.3%, admittedly off a much smaller base than the other categories. Service revenue increased by 19.9% and EBITDA grew by 22.1%, so there was further expansion in the EBITDA margin to 53.6%. The cash followed the earnings, with the interim dividend up 23.1%. Here’s the interesting thing though: capital expenditure is up 67.1% due to the rollout of the 4G network. Because of such extensive investment, free cash flow fell by 14.3%. MTN expects this scenario to normalise in the second half, benefitting free cash flow for the remainder of the year. With net debt to EBITDA of only 0.6x, the balance sheet is strong enough to cope with this. MTN is down 19% this year despite having strong operating momentum.
  • Ellies Holdings has released results for the year ended 30 April. Revenue fell by 10.8% and EBITDA plummeted by 148.8% into a nasty loss of R37.1 million vs. a profit of R76 million in the comparable period. The headline loss per share is -7.13 cents vs. headline earnings per share of 9.19 cents last year. Needless to say, there’s no dividend. The group was unable to deliver R119 million worth of orders due to unavailability of stock, which is a function of a weak balance sheet rather than major supply chain problems. To put even more pressure on working capital, Ellies is diversifying its revenue away from MultiChoice to solar, smart homes and water infrastructure. At this stage, Ellies hopes to rectify the balance sheet by “decreasing costs while simultaneously growing revenues” – certainly easier said than done.
  • Luxe Holdings is one of the most obscure companies on the JSE, with a market cap of just over R62 million and a portfolio of jewellery businesses. There have been many changes to directors and the company has now acknowledged that some transactions in the prior periods were not accounted for in accordance with IFRS. There’s never a dull moment at Luxe. Considering the latest trading statement is based on previously published numbers rather than correct numbers, I’m not sure how much weight can really be placed on them. For what it’s worth, headline earnings per share (HEPS) is expected to be between 31.49 cents and 39.52 cents, a swing into the green from the prior period’s headline loss per share of -80.3 cents.
  • Investec released its Basel III disclosures as at 30 June. This is the banking regulatory framework that measures the amount of equity a bank needs to retain on its balance sheet. It is a highly complicated assessment that requires intricate calculations of risk-weighted assets as the basis of the calculation. Investec’s balance sheet is healthy, with a 14.6% or 14.2% common equity tier 1 ratio depending how you treat unappropriated profits. Our banking system is world-class and remains in good health.

Operational updates

  • Glencore released its production report for the first half of the financial year. The company notes that when the financial report comes out during the next week, it will reflect the benefit of “buoyant energy markets” – that’s obviously a great sign, especially as the production numbers themselves weren’t great. Five commodities improved year-on-year and five dropped. The big winners were cobalt (up 40%) and nickel (up 21%), with the losers being gold and silver (both down 21%). In terms of full year guidance, copper has been decreased by 5% based on geotechnical constraints at Katanga along with other operations challenges. The share price closed over 3.3% higher on the day.
  • MC Mining has released an update for the quarter ended June 2022. Although coal production at Uitkomst was 7% lower year-on-year, the important news is that around 22,170 tonnes of coal were at the Durban port at the end of June for export. This has been made possible by the sales and marketing agreement with Overlooked, announced by the company on 28 July. Total sales volumes were far lower than the comparable period, with high grade metallurgical coal and thermal coal volumes down by around 66%. The company notes that Uitkomst didn’t receive a single order this quarter from its largest customer. The shift to export is clearly a strategic necessity and could prove to be lucrative, as the export prices are much higher. This quarter also saw the appointment of a few new directors (excluding ex-finance minister Nhlanhla Nene) and the raising of equity and debt capital. The share price went parabolic recently, climbing over 170% in July before calming down from R3.80 per share to R2.88. That’s a drop of 24% in a casual reminder of the dangers of buying a parabolic chart (one that suddenly shoots to the moon).
  • Montauk Renewables has announced the filing of a provisional patent application for a new acid neutralisation technology. Before pregnant women with heartburn celebrate too quickly, I’m afraid that this relates to acidic condensate produced when wastewater is removed from the biogas conversion process. The company explains that the acid does expensive damage to processing facilities and equipment. The classic alternatives of two Rennies or some Gaviscon appear to be safe for now.
  • Mantengu Mining has been suspended from trading since July 2016. In the latest quarterly update, the company reminds the market that the acquisition of Langpan Mining Co has become unconditional and that the effective date was 27 July 2022. The company has applied to the JSE to have its suspension lifted.

Share buybacks and dividends

  • Adcorp Holdings repurchased 0.66% of its shares in issue between 15 July and 18 July for an aggregate value of nearly R4 million.

Notable shuffling of (expensive) chairs

  • Altron is looking for a new company secretary and has appointed a company (FluidRock Governance Group) to act as interim company secretary. The legislation makes it possible to appoint a company to this role rather than an individual, which is why there are companies that provide company secretarial services.
  • Similarly, York Timber has appointed Kilgetty Statutory Services as company secretary of the company. The difference is that this appointment isn’t on an interim basis.

Director dealings

  • Rudolf Fourie is retiring as the CEO of Raubex Group and has sold some shares as “part of his retirement planning” – nearly R72 million worth of shares! Some retirements are far more comfortable than others. He has retained a stake in the company worth over R62 million.

Unusual things

  • Marcel Golding has taken the executive reins at Rex Trueform at a time when the group is clearly planning more deals, with the most recent example being the acquisition of a property from Spear REIT. The latest news is that Geomer Managerial Services (GMS) has been appointed as an advisor to Rex Trueform. Golding is a director of and shareholder in Geomer, so this is a related party transaction. The agreement will run until either 1 July 2024 or the payment in aggregate of R14 million in advisory fees, whichever happens sooner. Valeo Capital has concluded that the terms of the agreement are fair. Of course, there’s a difference between “fair” and “acceptable to investors” in terms of governance.

If you enjoyed Ghost Bites, then make sure you’re on the mailing list for a daily dose of market insights in Ghost Mail. It’s free! SIGN UP HERE >>>

Ghost Bites Vol 58 (22)

Corporate finance corner (M&A / capital raises)

  • Afrimat raised more money than expected, as R680 million is greater than the guidance given the prior day of a raise of 5% of the market cap. The company notes that there was strong demand for the shares, so it took advantage of this fact and gave its bank account a boost. The shares were issued at a 7.2% discount to the closing price the prior day, with investors suffering a 6.5% drop in the share price as a result. Remember, only institutional investors with deep pockets are approached to participate in an accelerated bookbuild.
  • Investec Property Fund announced in April that it had received unsolicited interest for its Pan-European Logistics platform. This kicked off a formal sales process which has now been stopped in its tracks by macroeconomic conditions. This is clearly not the best time to be selling anything in Europe. The good news is that the underlying portfolio has reduced vacancies and achieved positive reversions (lease renewals at a higher rate than the expired leases), so this is a pricing issue rather than a problem with the underlying business.
  • Castleview Property Fund has released the details of a reverse takeover and issue of shares for cash. This is a big transaction, including a number of Cape Town properties and a stake of over 50% in Emira Property Fund. This suddenly takes Castleview from an obscure fund with just two properties to being a mid-tier REIT with a net asset value of R5.5 billion. The seller of these assets is I Group Investments, which is effectively using the Castleview vehicle as a way to list these assets quickly.

Financial updates

  • ArcelorMittal South Africa released financial results for the six months ended June 2022. Although sales volumes fell by 8% and crude steel production fell by a whopping 30%, an increase in the realised steel price in dollars by 23% (driven by constrained supply in the wake of the Russia-Ukraine conflict) led to a strong result. Revenue grew by 19.3% and Headline Earnings Per Share (HEPS) grew by 21.5%. Net finance charges fell by 44% thanks to a 61% reduction in net debt, which clearly contributed to the bottom line result. EBITDA is a measure of profitability before interest charges (and a few other things) and this line grew by 11.6%, lower than revenue growth and thus reflecting a deterioration in EBITDA margin. The company’s raw material basket (iron ore, coking coal and scrap – collectively 43% of the cash cost per tonne) increased by 41% compared to a 39% increase in the international raw material basket. There was emphasis on the company’s Value Plan Programme which resulted in improvements worth R577 million in commercial-related initiatives as well as cost-based initiatives. In cyclical businesses like these, cost containment is critical. The 30% drop in crude steel production was blamed on external factors ranging from rail service issues (which led to the month-long shutdown of a Vanderbijlpark blast furnace as well as intermittent stops due to insufficient inventory in other furnaces) to loadshedding and floods. On top of all this, there was a two-week labour strike! Average capacity utilisation fell from 59% to 42%, with the company expecting a recovery to 76% after the Newcastle blast furnace mid-life campaign restoration. With economic pressures clearly visible, ArcelorMittal is focused on preserving the gains made in recent years and managing cash carefully in a downward cycle. Of course, the company will intensify its efforts under the Value Plan Programme to further reduce costs.
  • Sticking with mining, Anglo American Plc also released results for the six months ended June 2022. The balance sheet is looking incredibly healthy, with a net debt : annualised EBITDA ratio of just 0.3x. This has allowed the group to maintain its 40% payout policy, with a dividend of $1.24 per share. Still, HEPS came under pressure with a drop from $4.22 to $3.02. With a mining EBITDA margin of 52%, this is still a strong period for mining even if the year-on-year result doesn’t look great because of declining commodity prices and some production issues. The Quellaveco copper operation is an important driver of growth going forward, with the mine commissioned on time and on budget in this period. The share price is down nearly 13% this year.
  • Pepkor Holdings released a voluntary trading update for its third quarter ended 30 June 2022. The non-payment of the Social Relief of Distress grant had a significant negative impact on May and June, with the flooding April as another challenge. Still, 5.1% revenue growth for the quarter is hardly a failure. Like-for-like sales were flat in Pep and Ackermans, which talks to the point around the grants and the damage to the distribution centre in April, which is currently only operating at 50% capacity. It is expected to operate at 80% capacity in the next month, although sales have already suffered due to this inefficiency. The R1 billion estimated damage from the floods (including disruption of operations) is fully insured and the group expects to receive an interim payment before the end of September 2022. Importantly, the local credit business is healthy and collections are at satisfactory levels. The Brazilian Grupo Avenida business is flying, with sales up 51.6% in constant currency. This acquisition will contribute 2% to group revenue this year and 4% next year. Looking beyond clothes, the furniture, appliances and electronics segment (mainly JD Group) grew by 3.7% and the building materials segment fell by 1.9% in line with what we’ve seen from other players in that market. The FinTech segment (Flash) changed its product mix and experienced a decrease in revenue. The group also received R517 million as a further interim payment from SASRIA for the July civil unrest, after R500 million was received in the previous financial year. An R80 million interim insurance payment for business interruption was also received by the group during this quarter, taking the total insurance payments for business interruption to R383 million. Although the group acknowledges the risks of rising inflation, it is pleased with the reinstatement of the Social Relief of Distress grant which will greatly assist its lower-income customers. Trading during July was strong and exceeded expectations.
  • The Foschini Group (TFG) released a trading update for the first quarter of FY23 and the numbers look good, with retail turnover growth of 16.3%. TFG Africa grew by 11.2% (and 7.1% on a like-for-like basis), with Clothing up 13.1% and Homeware up 17.4%, confirming market share gains in both categories. The strategy to localise the supply chain continues to pay dividends here (literally). TFG Australia grew revenue by 15.7% in constant currency. TFG London did even better (with the recent update from competitor Truworths as another indication of better trading in the UK), with turnover up a whopping 39.9% in constant currency. At group level, online turnover grew 13.2% and now contributes 9.7% of total turnover, down from 10.2% in the comparable period. Looking segmentally, online turnover contributes 3.2% of TFG Africa’s turnover, 38.4% of TFG London’s turnover and 6.5% of TFG Australia’s turnover. TFG also confirmed that the effective date for the acquisition of Tapestry Home Brands is 1 August 2022, as all conditions have been met. Trading momentum is strong into July, with some silly numbers due to Covid disruptions in the base (e.g. TFG Australia is up 72.8% for the first three weeks of July).
  • Karooooo Limited has released results for its first quarter ended May 2022. The company experienced Cartrack subscriber growth of 13%, with far fewer net additions in this quarter than the comparable quarter. The South African subscriber base was flat vs. the preceding quarter due to numerous external challenges in the local market. Cadence is strong though, with more net additions just in June than in the entire quarter ended May! There seems to be some traction in Southeast Asia at long last, though there is a long way to go. Total revenue increased by 28% year-on-year and subscription revenue (the one that really matters – R709 million out of R801 million total revenue) increased by 17%. Encouragingly, profit for the period increased by 44% and earnings per share increased by 42%. Cash generated from operations also headed in the right way (up 17%) although there were more payment defaults in South Africa due to inflationary pressures and the KwaZulu-Natal floods. The share price has clawed its way back to R405 and I still hold a stake in the business, albeit a smaller one than before as I trimmed it a few months back.
  • MiX Telematics operates as a competitor to Karooooo and released results for the quarter ended June 2022. Subscription revenue was down slightly as reported and up 6.3% on a constant currency basis. Subscription revenue is 88.3% of total revenue. Gross margin fell from 65.5% to 62.0%. An increase in sales and marketing costs really hit net margin though, which fell from 12.4% to 6.9%. Significant capital expenditure (mainly in vehicle tracking devices) led to negative free cash flow.
  • Anheuser-Busch InBev released results for the second quarter of 2022. Revenue increased by 11.3% and total volumes rose by 3.4%. Own beer volumes were up 2.7% and non-beer volumes were up 8.2%. There was a 9.7% increase in revenue of global brands (Corona, Stella Artois and Budweiser) beyond their home markets.  Around 55% of revenue is now coming from the company’s B2B (Business-to-business) channels. Normalised EBITDA increased by 7.2%, with EBITDA margin falling by 127 basis points. Underlying earnings per share decreased from $0.75 in the comparable period to $0.73. Net debt to EBITDA improved slightly from 3.96x at the end of 2021 to 3.86x at the end of June 2022. The company expects EBITDA to grow between 4%- 8% in the medium term and revenue to grow at a higher rate, which is a roundabout way of saying that more margin pressures are coming. For the first six months of the financial year, HEPS increased by 15% to $1.43.
  • Hammerson Plc closed 7.9% higher after releasing interim results. Adjusted earnings jumped by a rather spectacular 154%, with Covid impacts in the base period as an obvious contributor to this. There are other good news stories unrelated to the pandemic though, like a 20% decrease in gross administration costs and a 25% decrease in net finance costs. Net debt was reduced by 6% through asset disposals. Footfall at the retail properties reached 90% of 2019 levels and sales were ahead of 2019 levels in the second quarter. On a proportionally consolidated basis, loan to value improved from 39% at the end of 2021 to 37% by June 2022. An interim dividend of 0.2 pence per share has been declared and the board hopes to offer an enhanced scrip dividend of 2.0 pence per share, subject to shareholder approval.
  • Royal Bafokeng Platinum released a trading statement for the six months ended June 2022. Although production increased by 4.5%, the drop in PGM prices and impact of inflation on operations led to a drop in HEPS of 58.1%. The market knows these things already as the commodity prices are observable at all times, so the share price hardly budged.
  • Mpact Limited put out a trading statement for the six months ended June and the share price responded by closing 4.6% higher. Exports were reduced in the containerboard business, leading to a favourable mix effect. The paper business was driven by industrial and quick service restaurant customers, with fruit exporters lower due to supply chain issues. The plastics business was a mixed bag across the various products. Mpact is in discussions to exit the Versapak business. Net debt increased significantly, driven by capital expenditure and working capital outflows. HEPS from continuing operations is expected to be between 22.8% and 27.0% higher, as the company successfully managed a tricky period of inflationary pressures.
  • Mediclinic has released a trading update and has reiterated its guidance for the full year. The happy news for everyone is that Covid-related admissions have obviously decreased substantially. Switzerland is expected to deliver “modest growth” in FY23 and EBITDA margin improvement to 16%. Southern Africa is expected to achieve revenue growth in the mid-single digit percentage range and an EBITDA margin improvement to nearly 20%. The Middle East is expected to delivery revenue growth in the mid-single digit percentage range and EBITDA improvement to around 15.5%.
  • Montauk Renewables will be releasing its second quarter results on 9th August, in case you’re so excited that you want to diarise it.

Operational updates

  • Orion Minerals released an operating update for the quarter ended June 2022. It was a very busy period, with $87 million in funding secured from Canadian company Triple Flag and the commencement of a three-tranche capital raising exercise with a target of $20 million. The trouble is that many parties who were set to participate in the capital raise have asked for “additional time to consider their involvement” given the broader economic challenges. The team is also figuring out how to bring the Prieska Project development schedule forward, even on a reduced scale if needed. The group also made significant progress with a strategic partnership in the battery materials sector, a growth area of note.
  • MC Mining released an unusual announcement in which it cautioned shareholders about the uncertainty in the business in the wake of recent share price increases. The price closed 15.8% lower, so I guess it did the job of dampening enthusiasm. The group is working on funding for the Makhado hard coking coal project, expected to be a combination of debt and equity. There are also ongoing performance improvement initiatives at Uitkomst, including the announcement of a sales and marketing agreement that gives the company access to an export allocation at coal ports. This is a related party transaction as the counterparty to the agreement is owned by a non-executive director of MC Mining.

Share buybacks and dividends

Notable shuffling of (expensive) chairs

  • Life Healthcare has appointed two new non-executive directors to the board who both come with extensive global experience. The group is focused on its offshore footprint and these appointments are clearly in line with that strategy.
  • Pembury Lifestyle Group (currently suspended from trading) has appointed three new non-executive directors and a new Designated Advisor (required by each company listed on the AltX) as part of the plan to achieve a lifting of the suspension.

Director dealings

  • A director of a major subsidiary of Stefanutti Stocks has bought shares in the holding company worth nearly R84k.
  • A non-executive director of British American Tobacco has bought shares in the company (on the US market) worth around $150k.

Unusual things

  • PSG Konsult’s credit rating has been affirmed by GCR with a stable outlook.

If you enjoyed Ghost Bites, then make sure you’re on the mailing list for a daily dose of market insights in Ghost Mail. It’s free! SIGN UP HERE >>>

Who’s doing what this week in the South African M&A space?

Exchange Listed Companies

Castleview Property Fund has announced a R5 billion deal with the acquisition of a number of real estate assets including the Willowbridge retail properties, the K346 development properties, iRes residential properties, the entire share capital of Tensai Property Services and more than 50% of the issued shares in Emira Property Fund. If implemented, Castleview will issue shares in excess of 100% of the existing Castleview shares in issue, resulting in a reverse take-over of the company. In addition to the acquisitions and as part of the transaction, the company has announced the issue for cash of a further 51,91 million shares to the Womens Soccer League (34,9m shares) and Streepperdjie (17m shares) at R5.97 per share for a total R309,9 million.

Investec Property Fund has advised shareholders that the current global macroeconomic volatility has resulted in placing on hold its planned sale of the Pan-European Logistics portfolio.

RCL FOODS has acquired KZN-based Sunshine Bakery, a company indirectly majority-owned by AFGRI Group for an undisclosed sum. The acquisition will increase bread volumes in the company’s baking network by 28%.

Equites Property Fund is to dispose of six logistics warehouses in Cape Town to investor consortium Mabel Black Knight Investments for R190 million. As part of the transaction Equites will provide training and facilitate the skills transfer process to Mabel which will enhance their property expertise.

Rex Trueform and Spear REIT have entered into a sale agreement whereby Rex Trueform will acquire the property 5 Fitzmaurice Avenue in Epping, Cape Town for a gross purchase consideration of R85 million. The acquisiton is seen by the company as a strategic opportunity to diversify and grow its existing property portfolio.

Unlisted Companies

Local startup Qwili, a platform providing hybrid hardware-software product to micro and small merchants in South Africa, has closed a seed funding round raising US$1,2 million. The round was led by E4E Africa with participation from Strat-Tech, Next Chymia, Untapped Global and Codec Ventures. The investment will be used for app development and hardware production.

The sale by BP Southern Africa of a 50% interest in the Cape Town Terminal to the Central Energy Fund’s Strategic Fuel Fund has received approval from the Competition Commission.

Impresa Capital, a Durban-based venture capital firm, has acquired Gumtree South Africa for an undisclosed sum from Norwegian company Adevinta. Impresa Capital is a majority shareholder of Ignition Group, one of Africa’s largest investors in technology, media, telecommunications and financial services.

DealMakers is SA’s M&A publication
www.dealmakerssouthafrica.com

Verified by MonsterInsights