The South African rand weakened to the US dollar by 3.1% in February , despite the strong start shown on 1 February. The Budget Speech delivered on 21 February also didn’t seem to arrest the slide, with the rand weakening sharply a day after the annual Budget. Domestic markets followed this trend, with the FTSE/JSE All Share Index (ALSI) ending the month down -2.44% after a sharp increase immediately after the Budget Speech, followed by an even sharper decline two trading days later.
Following back-to-back ALSI monthly declines of more than 2% each in 2024, local equity losses were almost entirely concentrated to Resource companies in February, with the Resource index declining 7.17% for the month. The Property index was up 0.8%, with Financials and Industrials indices marginally down -0.84 and -0.69% respectively. Local investors with offshore exposure saw some reprieve, with the MSCI World Index up 7,5% in rand terms (buoyed by its high exposure to US companies), and the S&P 500 Index returning 8.65% in rand terms.
This points to a deeper principle that seasoned investors abide by: having exposure to different assets, industries, and geographies. International funds solve this through country-specific exposure or by achieving an assortment of countries in one basket, ensuring that even if the rand slides, the investor stands to gain.
Growth in Leaps and Bounds
All international indices tracked by Satrix realised positive growth in dollar terms last month, including the MSCI China Index (up 11.8%% in rands), which we highlighted as an underperformer in our last two newsletters. The MSCI India Index returned 5.9% in rands, while the broader MSCI Emerging Markets Index, of which China makes up a quarter, climbed 8.05% in rand terms.
The newly listed Satrix MSCI ACWI ETF, which includes both developed and emerging market indices and is one of the most diversified indices, also achieved positive growth in February 2024, climbing 0.98% since listing on 22 February.
International investors will be hoping that 2024 bucks the historical trend of the US market contracting by 2% during leap years. According to CNN, leap years have returned 10.8% on the S&P versus non-leap year returns of 12.8%, on average. Locally, the ALSI has returned, on average, 18.8% annually since 1996 during non-leap years, while returning a pedestrian 3.5% average return during leap years (granted, 2008 was a leap year too). But before we leap to any conclusions, perhaps this year will be different.
A New Tax-Free Season
March 1 marked the beginning of the new tax season, which means a new opportunity to make the most of your investments by harnessing the benefits of the tax-free savings account (TFSA). Your TFSA allows you to invest in funds without having to pay income, interest, or capital gains tax to SARS on any returns you may earn (provided you stay within the legislated contribution limits across all of your tax-free savings accounts.
For more information about how the TFSA works and its opportunities, click here.
SatrixNOW is a no-minimum online investing platform from Satrix that allows you to buy and sell ETFs directly.
The Ghost Wrap podcast is proudly brought to you by Mazars, a leading international audit, tax and advisory firm with a national footprint within South Africa. Visit the Mazars website for more information.
In this episode of Ghost Wrap, I covered these important stories on the local market:
Mustek is a lesson in two things: the danger of a value trap and the threat of competition in lucrative sector.
Curro is telling the market that it wants to fill its schools, yet the company increased fees by a much higher rate than inflation in 2023.
Sea Harvest is another good example of a corporate that saw a sharp rise in net finance costs, yet the dividend payout ratio moved higher.
Quilter is an offshore business that is doing a great job of growing its operations in the UK, making it a compelling rand hedge for South African investors.
Brian McMillan of the Structured Products team at Investec is back on Ghost Stories, this time to talk about the Investec Nikkei 225 Autocall.
This product is designed to give investors exposure to the Nikkei 225 index over a period of up to five years with an enhanced return of up to 17% per annum in ZAR or 11.5% per annum in USD. Importantly, there is 100% capital protection provided the index does not drop by more than 30%.
To help you understand this opportunity, the topics covered include:
The history of the Nikkei 225 over the past three decades and how it became ignored by investors, with the narrative having improved significantly in recent times.
Reasons why the Nikkei 225 could be a compelling investment going forward.
The structure of an “autocall” product and exactly how it works over the time period of the instrument.
The way the upside works on this instrument, with a fixed return provided the index closes above the starting level.
The underlying credit risk in the instrument.
The liquidity in the note and the extent to which it is tradeable during the term.
The minimum investment amount required and how the fees work.
Confirmation of the types of investors allowed to participate.
The investment tranche is available until the 5th of April 2024.
As always you must do your own research and speak to your financial advisor before investing in a product like this. You can find all the information you need on the Investec website at this link.
Get the latest recap of JSE news in the Ghost Wrap podcast, brought to you by Mazars:
Exxaro’s earnings dropped in 2023 (JSE: EXX)
Lower export sales prices hurt the business
Exxaro is a coal operation that for some reason also owns a wind energy business. I’m not kidding. Sadly, improved wind conditions in 2023 (no, really) couldn’t offset the knock taken by the coal business, so earnings are down for the year.
The major challenge was in export sales prices, which couldn’t be fully offset by improved domestic prices and the weaker rand. The net result is that EBITDA is expected to be between 23% and 37% lower for the year.
At HEPS level, the expected drop is 16% to 30%.
A year to remember for Grindrod (JSE: GND)
The core business is flying
Grindrod has released its results for the year ended December 2023 and they look great. The core business could only grow revenue by 1%, but EBITDA jumped by 16% and headline earnings from this part of the group grew by 29%.
Talk about doing a lot with a little.
In case you’re wondering, the revenue issue was because of reduced value added services mineral export sales and charters. Within the broader business, an operation like the port in Maputo did exceptionally well (record volumes up by 28% vs. the prior period).
The non-core business is far less positive, with fair value losses on the private equity portfolio and and property loans in KZN.
At group level, HEPS was up 18%. The full year dividend was up by a whopping 84% for the year.
Lighthouse Properties acquires a mall in Spain (JSE: LTE)
The deal is worth EUR 121 million
Lighthouse has been telling the market that the focus is on direct property acquisitions. They haven’t wasted any time, entering into an agreement to acquire Centro Comercial H2O in Spain for EUR 121 million.
This mall is in Madrid and opened in 2007. It has a strong offering of tenants, which is probably why bank debt of EUR 61.5 million is available to support the deal. The purchase price is a net initial yield of 7.5% and the forecast distributable profit for the 12 months ending December 2025 is EUR 5.233 million.
This increases Lighthouse’s exposure to Spain, with the Iberian portfolio now constituting 66% of the value of Lighthouse’s directly held properties.
OUTsurance had a wild ride at segmental level (JSE: OUT)
At group level, it’s a sideways story
OUTsurance released a voluntary trading update for the six months ended December 2023. It’s voluntary because group earnings won’t differ by more than 20%. As for segmentals, buckle up.
OUTsurance Ireland is rather funny, with the R2 million loss in the prior worsening by 2,800%. You read that correctly. Of course, the percentage is nonsensical. The story here is that they are setting up the Irish business and incurring start-up losses.
The South African short-term business expects normalised earnings to be between -8% and 2% different to the comparable period. That suggests a negative mid-point.
Youi Group in Australia is expected to be down by between -20% and -10%, reflecting higher “natural perils” claims particularly in Australia. I presume this excludes all the spiders and snakes.
The highlight is the life insurance business, which casually grew earnings by 400% off a low base. I warned you that the segmentals are a bit wild.
With all said and done, group normalised earnings will be between -5% and 5% different to the comparable year. In other words, a mid-point of flat earnings. HEPS is expected to be a -6% to 4% difference.
Sanlam had a great time in 2023 (JSE: SLM)
The dividend for the year grew 11%
Sanlam enjoyed a significant improvement in its fortunes in 2023. There are many numbers you could look at here, but the cash net result from financial services (up 18%) is one of the better choices. You could also consider HEPS being 48% higher as a solid indication of how the year went.
Perhaps the best indication of all is the growth in the full year dividend per share, which was 11%.
Some of the major drivers of this performance include the better life insurance risk experience, improved investment market levels and general growth in the books at Sanlam. They also highlight the credit business in India as a useful contributor.
There’s a lot of positive sentiment towards India at the moment as growth comes under pressure in China. Sanlam seems to be well positioned for that.
Earnings growth continues at STADIO (JSE: SDO)
Tertiary education is a lucrative business
For the year ended December 2023, STADIO achieved a set of numbers that shareholders won’t be upset about. At a time when most South African companies are treading water in terms of earnings growth, STADIO achieved an increase in HEPS of between 17.6% and 27.6%. Core HEPS was between 14.1% and 24.1% higher.
Whichever way you cut it, that’s good.
Adjusted HEPS is up slightly at Sun International (JSE: SUI)
Some parts of the business are doing better than others
Sun International has released a trading statement dealing with the year ended December 2023. It’s a mixed bag at divisional level, with only some commentary to go on at the moment rather than actual numbers. SunBet is achieving record income, the resorts and hotels had an “exceptional year” and the urban casinos and Sun Slots “demonstrated resilience” – so there were clearly pressures there.
Overall, adjusted HEPS for the year is expected to come in between 4% and 9% higher. This implies a level of between 456 cents and 478 cents per share.
If we look at HEPS without adjustments, there’s a wild swing that sees an increase of between 82% and 92%. This is due to adjustments related to a put option liability, transaction costs on the Peermont acquisition and the devaluation of the naira. Perhaps the range is more important than the percentage here, as HEPS would be between 412 cents and 434 cents per share.
Importantly, South African debt has reduced from R5.9 billion to R5.7 billion, despite the company paying R985 million in dividends. South African debt to adjusted EBITDA is 1.7 times.
Things seem to be improving at Trellidor (JSE: TRL)
HEPS is down but so is net debt
Trellidor has been through a really tough time. It’s good to see that they are making progress on two major initiatives: international revenue (now 28.2% of the group total) and reduction of net debt (down from R140.3 million to R116.8 million).
Profitability is still a challenge, with HEPS dropping by 16.1% despite group revenue increasing by 6.9%. This is because borrowing costs are putting the group under pressure, which is why there is still no dividend as the group prioritises the reduction of debt.
Little Bites:
Director dealings:
The CEO of Bidcorp (JSE: BID) has sold shares in the company worth R11.7 million. This time around, the announcement specifies that this is to settle tax obligations.
Nobody knows what the cluck is going on at Quantum Foods (JSE: QFH), with the share price closing 73% higher today on big volumes. The only announcement in the market was that Astral Foods (JSE: ARL) has sold its 9.77% stake in the company.
Curro (JSE: COH) has repurchased shares worth R211 million between 15 June 2023 and 6 March 2024. The average price paid is R9.96, which compares favourably to the current market price of R11.35.
Heriot REIT (JSE: HET) has acquired shares in Safari Investments (JSE: SAR) from Reya Gola Investments, a related party, to the value of R4.5 million. The purchase price is R5.60 per share which is in line with the current market price. Reya Gola is an entity related to Steven Herring.
Hillie Meyer just can’t get enough of Momentum Metropolitan (JSE: MTM) and they can’t get enough of him. He was CEO from 1996 to 2005. Then he was CEO once more from 2018 to 2023. He has now been appointed as a non-executive director of the group.
After the resignation of the CFO at Texton (JSE: TEX) announced all the way back in December 2022, the group has appointed the CEO of Texton as part-time Financial Director until a permanent appointment is made. If the capital allocation policy of the company isn’t enough to worry you, perhaps the governance is.
Labat Africa (JSE: LAB) announced the resignation of its financial director with effect from 31 March 2024. The company still hasn’t appointed an auditor but has received proposals from a number of audit firms. The audit committee is due to consider the appointment of an auditor this month.
Mantengu Mining (JSE: MTU) has issued shares to settle creditors with total debt of R7.45 million. The creditors were willing to accept shares at a price of R1.50 per share, which is much higher than the current price of R0.85.
Astoria Investments (JSE: ARA) has renewed the cautionary announcement that was first issued in July 2023. Negotiations are still ongoing in respect of a potential acquisition.
The RCL Foods board has given its preliminary approval for the unbundling and listing of Rainbow Chicken, a move first mooted some years ago. The move will allow the company to focus on its branded foods business.
Lighthouse Properties, through its wholly-owned Spanish subsidiary, is to acquire the retail shopping centre known as Centro Commercial H2O, together with a vacant plot of land detached from H2O. The gross purchase consideration is €121 million which includes deferred capital expenditure of €10 million. Net of existing senior bank debt of €61,5 million, the purchase consideration will be funded from existing cash resources.
Following last week’s ruling by SA’s Takeover Regulations Panel, French media company Canal+ has been granted an extension to 8 April to publish a firm intention announcement to acquire MultiChoice shares from minorities. The media company has upped its mandatory offer from R105 to R125 per share, valuing the company at R55,3 billion. The initial offer price was higher than that paid when it acquired the latest shares on market and tipped it over the 35% threshold, triggering a mandatory offer to minorities. Even so, the R105 offer was rejected by MultiChoice as significantly undervaluing the group whose net asset value sits at c. R181 a share.
Hulamin has acquired the remaining stake in Isizinda Aluminium from joint venture partner Bingelela Capital. The primary activity of Isizinda is the management of properties. Prior to the transaction, Hulamin held a 38.7% stake.
MC Mining has appealed to its shareholders not to accept the off-market takeover bid of A$1.16 per share by Goldway Capital Investment. The offer will remain open until 5 April 2024 unless it is extended or withdrawn by Goldway.
The disinvestment by Gold Fields of its 45% effective interest in Asanko Gold Mine to Galiano Gold for gross proceeds of US$170m, has closed with all conditions precedent fulfilled on March 4, 2024. Goldfields received US$65 million in cash and 28,5 million shares in Galiano as upfront proceeds for the divestment. The remaining proceeds will be settled through deferred and contingent payments.
Unlisted Companies
Last-mile delivery and express parcel services company The Courier Guy, has been acquired by private equity firm Adenia Partners alongside co-investors DEG, Proparco and South Suez. Financial details were undisclosed.
The launch of a new, majority black owned venture capital fund, Conducive Capital, will invest in early- and growth-stage disruptive technologies. The fund aims to raise, in its first close in July 2024, US$15 million with a target final close of $50 million within 24 months.
French energy giant TotalEnergies and Qatar’s state-owned oil company QatarEnergy have together acquired a majority stake in an exploration licence of Block 3B/4B in the Orange Basin, off South Africa’s west coast. TotalEnergies acquired a 33% participating interest while QatarEnergy has taken a 24% interest. The stakes were acquired from existing shareholders Africa Oil South Africa, Ricocure and Azinam.
Astral has disposed of its minority 9.8% stake in Quantum Foods for an aggregate consideration of R141,7 million. The transaction, executed through a book over, was acquired by Country Bird at R7.25 per share – a 70% premium to the current market value.
Heriot Properties, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Heriot REIT, has acquired an additional 807 069 Safari Investments RSA shares from Reya Gola for a purchase consideration of R5.60 per share and an aggregate purchase consideration of R4,5 million. The purchase was executed by way of a cash settled on-market block trade on the JSE. Following the acquisition, Heriot Properties and its concert parties (excluding Reya Gola) will hold a 58.8% stake in Safari.
Lighthouse Properties has disposed of, on the open market, 164,973,138 Hammerson shares for an aggregate cash consideration of R1,02 billion.
Certain parties to loan contracts with Mantengu Mining have agreed to convert their debt claims against the company into equity at a rate of R1.50 of debt per Mantengu Mining share. The rate is a 93.58% premium to the 30-day VWAP prior to the date on which the settlement was agreed (29 February 2024).
Kibo Energy has announced the issue of 81,081,081 ordinary shares at an issue price of 0.00037 pence per share to a service provider in payment of outstanding invoices for a total value of £30,000.
Jubilee Metals has issued 9 million shares at an average price of 2.11 pence per option share following the exercise by an option holder. After the issue, the company will have 2,983,493,617 ordinary shares in issue.
A number of companies announced the repurchase of shares.
Brimstone Investment has, since its December year-end, repurchased 1,5 million ‘N’ shares for an aggregate R7,2 million.
Curro has repurchased an aggregate 21,201,450 shares during the period 15 June 2023 to 6 March 2024. The shares were repurchased at an average price per share of R9.97 for an aggregate purchase consideration of R21,2 million.
Invicta has concluded an intra-group repurchase with Humulani Marketing, a wholly-owned subsidiary of the company, in terms of which it acquired 762,492 shares from Humulani at a repurchase price of R26.92 per share. The shares will be held by Invicta in treasury.
The price for Adcorp’s odd-lot offer has been finalised. Those shareholders accepting the offer will receive R4.01 per share which represents a 5% premium to the 30-day VWAP at the close of business on 4 March 2024.
Prosus and Naspers continued with their open-ended share repurchase programmes. During the period 26 February to 1 March 2024, a further 3,804,685 Prosus shares were repurchased for an aggregate €104,12 million and a further 268,583 Naspers shares, for a total consideration of R861,13 million.
AB InBev has repurchased a further 850,371 shares at an average price of €56.60 per share for an aggregate €48,13 million. The shares were repurchased over the period 26 February to 1 March 2024.
In August 2022 the trading of Afristrat Investment’s shares were suspended on the JSE. Since then, the company has been unable to make additional progress with regards to its restructuring initiative process due to its suspension and liquidation application. In its announcement, the company noted that as at 1 March 2023 it was unable to pay its debt and did not meet the solvency and liquidity test as required by the JSE. As a result, the company was commercially insolvent and would proceed with a liquidation application.
Three companies issued profit warnings this week: MTN, Exxaro Resources and OUTsurance.
Two companies either issued, renewed, or withdrew cautionary notices this week: MultiChoice and Astoria Investment.
While the Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE) remains Africa’s largest and most liquid stock market1, new equity listings and capital raising activity has decreased significantly over recent years (Figure 1). As this has corresponded with a large number of delistings, the pool of listed equity investment opportunities on the JSE has shrunk over this period. Some of this decline may be attributable to global macroeconomic factors, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, a volatile inflation and interest rate environment, and geopolitical tensions such as the Russia-Ukraine war, which have impacted global equity prices. However, as a developing country and relatively new democracy, South Africa (SA) also has some of its own unique and well publicised political, economic and infrastructure challenges, which have, at times, exacerbated the general risk-off approach towards emerging and frontier markets, and the flight of capital to perceived safe-haven assets2.
Figure 1 – Number of new equity listings on the JSE Source: JSE
The trends (Figure 1) are not unique to SA, with other international exchanges, such as the London Stock Exchange (LSE), also seeing limited appetite for new equity listings over recent years. However, the picture for the NASDAQ is more positive (Figure 2), with that exchange having benefitted from numerous technology companies coming to market. By contrast, only 5.6% of equity listings on the JSE are in the technology sector3.
Figure 2 – Number of new equity listings on the LSE, New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) and NASDAQ Source: S&P Capital IQ Pro
What we did see in SA was an increase in the deployment of private equity (PE) capital into technology-related businesses. The allocation to information technology increased from 1.0% in 2019 to 5.8% in 2022 (Figure 3)4, with a larger share also going to financial services, indicating a potential link with fintech. Is this a result of the early-stage nature of many of these endeavours, or has PE capital emerged as a preferred source of investment to fund growth, rather than the public markets?
Figure 3 – Allocation of PE capital in SA to information technology and financial services Source: South African Venture Capital and Private Equity Association Survey 2023
In 2022, South African technology companies raised US$830m through 95 rounds of PE funding, constituting 17% of the total funding, and 14% of the overall deal count, for PE-related technology transactions in Africa5.
Increased costs, additional regulation and rigorous reporting requirements are regularly cited as reasons for companies to avoid public listings. Critics argue that these restrict the ability to be entrepreneurial and agile, which is especially relevant to early-stage growth companies where heightened scrutiny from the wider investor community and media restricts one’s ability to manoeuvre.
While managing listed companies (and public opinion) comes with its challenges, it brings with it the benefit of deep pools of capital in SA. Many institutional investors hold that regulation and reporting requirements can be advantageous, contending that effective management should possess the discipline and skills to handle these aspects as an integral part of business operations and growth. Retail investors also benefit from the additional regulatory protection in the listed environment.
Interestingly, as ESG becomes increasingly influential in capital allocation, whether for public or private investment, and PE capital expands (partly due to a shrinking listed universe), one might anticipate a convergence in certain regulatory standards and investment criteria between the two markets over time. The cost of sound advice and rigorous systems should be outweighed by the long-term benefits of building a transparent, accountable and sustainable business, able to draw on deeper pools of capital.
Will there be a tipping point where new equity listings return to public markets in SA, with robust systems to allow for transparency and ease of trade? Or will PE develop over time, to the point where it can provide a similar offering to retail investors? While the increased prominence of PE is likely here to stay, we expect that listed markets will, over the long term, continue to provide an effective platform to sufficiently mature companies seeking to raise capital for continued growth. In an environment that offers transparency, deep pools of capital and an enhanced profile, companies can also continue to grow acquisitively through issuing shares that have earned a premium by demonstrating their ability to run a business under wider scrutiny.
Will SA have its own tech listing boom when private capital markets have played their role in funding startup and early-stage businesses that have been developed locally and reached a point of maturity fit for public markets? While the JSE may benefit from SA’s position as one of the largest hubs for innovation in Africa, the NASDAQ can be attractive to SA technology companies as it has, at times, seen substantially higher valuations being achieved for new tech listings. However, it may be sensible for SA technology companies to consider a JSE listing as a first step, allowing them to establish a track record with investors and build their profile, thereby better positioning themselves for a potential future international listing.
1 Riscura and BrightAfrica – Liquidity (https://brightafrica.riscura.com/listed-equity/liquidity/#:~:text=The%20Johannesburg%20Stock%20Exchange%20(JSE,USD%201%20431m%20traded%20daily) 2 Riscura and Bright Africa – Liquidity 3 JSE 4 South African Venture Capital and Private Equity Association Survey 2023 (https://savca.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/SAVCA-PE-Survey-2023-Electronic.pdf) 5 2022 Partech Africa Report (https://partech-admin.prod.unomena.io/media/documents/2022_Partech_Africa_Tech_VC_Report.pdf)
Terence Kretzmann is a Director and Bhargav Desai a Junior Corporate Financier | PSG Capital.
This article first appeared in DealMakers, SA’s quarterly M&A publication
Get the latest recap of JSE news in the Ghost Wrap podcast, brought to you by Mazars:
Growth continues at ADvTECH (JSE: ADH)
Enrolments at the schools are in line with targets for 2024
ADvTECH has released a trading statement for the year ended December 2023, reflecting growth in HEPS of between 16% and 21%. That’s really good. They also report normalised earnings per share to strip out corporate action costs and once-off transactions, with that metric up by between 17% and 22%.
Whichever way you cut it, the numbers seem to be appealing. ADvTECH notes that all divisions contributed to the performance and that enrolments at the schools are in line with targets for 2024, so that bodes well for the new financial year as well.
Brimstone: debt reduction and share buybacks (JSE: BRT)
But why such a high dividend?
Brimstone is an investment holding company that holds a wide variety of interests. Some are controlling stakes and others are minority holdings, so you end up with a rather odd scenario of an investment holding company preparing consolidated accounts with all the different line items. I don’t think that is helpful for decision makers, so I ignore the income statement.
The balance sheet and supporting notes is where I think you’ll find what you need here. The intrinsic net asset value (or INAV) is management’s view of what the assets are worth. They show it in great detail and arrive at R12.13 per share, down from R13.25 per share a year ago. The share price closed 17% lower at R4.56, so the discount to INAV is vast.
How does this discount get closed? Much of it is structural, of course. Still, a strategy of disposing of assets at a price close to or at the INAV and then buying back Brimstone shares at a deep discount does wonders in companies like these. It just requires the directors to consciously decide to make the group smaller, which is where this often becomes a problem.
Brimstone is selling off certain investments and has reduced debt by R307.5 million since the end of December. During the year ended December 2023, the company repurchased shares worth R21.6 million, with more repurchases of R7.2 million subsequent to year-end. That all sounds like good stuff.
Unfortunately for shareholders, the company also insists on paying out a high proportion of HEPS as a cash dividend, despite the discount to INAV. This immediately makes me feel that the group is more of a cash cow for the controlling shareholders rather than a serious attempt at reducing the gap to INAV for minority shareholders. With HEPS of 71.6 cents and a dividend of 40 cents per share despite the vast discount to INAV, this is why I don’t hold shares in Brimstone.
Losses have narrowed at Murray & Roberts (JSE: MUR)
The debt also looks far better, but there’s a long way to go here
Murray & Roberts has lived through troubled times recently. Although revenue and EBITDA have both moved higher, the real highlight is the massive swing from an attributable loss of R2.5 billion to just R95 million. A loss should never be celebrated, but the context is important here.
The diluted headline loss per share from continuing operations came in from 16 cents rather than 27 cents in the comparable period, so losses have also narrowed on a headline basis with impairments and other issues stripped out.
The most important line is net debt, which has improved dramatically from R1.97 billion to R247 million.
Based on these numbers, it shouldn’t surprise you that no dividend will be declared for the full year ending June 2024. At least you’ve been warned. Instead, the company will be focusing on a sustainable capital structure and bedding down the new operational structure that sees the managing directors of the four operating companies all appointed to the group board.
Group CEO Henry Laas has agreed to stick around until August 2025.
Mustek will want to forget about 2023 (JSE: MST)
Cheap stocks can stay cheap – and still rise and fall with earnings
When you’re buying a stock on a low earnings multiple, you need to still be careful of a value trap. There needs to be some kind of catalyst for the multiple to move higher sustainably, otherwise all that happens is the multiple stays consistently low and the share price flaps around based on the financial results anyway.
At Mustek, the low trailing multiple turned out to be a sensible approach from the market. Investors were wary of whether the good times could continue. Spoiler alert: they couldn’t.
For the six months to December 2023, revenue fell 13%, gross profit margin contracted by 70 basis points to 13.4% and operating profit was down 25.3%.
By the time you get to HEPS, it’s down 58.81% from 221.74 cents to 91.34 cents. Although this is only an interim number, the share price of R10.34 suddenly doesn’t look like such a bargain.
And in case you’re wondering, the joy of capitalist competition is playing out in green energy products. This has been a major source of the reduction in gross profit. When you are thinking about a business, you always have to consider the threat of competition in a lucrative space and what this would do for prices.
Quilter celebrates record profitability (JSE: QLT)
Go with the flows
Quilter is a UK-based asset and wealth management business that understands the importance of a distribution strategy to attract inflows. In simple terms: they are quite good at selling investment products. This is absolutely critical to manage periods of tough returns in the market. When times are good, this is a flywheel effect that leads to great profits.
How do you measure this? Core business net inflows. Although they will definitely be volatile each year (as we saw at Quilter in 2023 where they were far lower than the prior year), the point is that inflows are good and outflows are bad. Provided assets are still growing, the asset manager is doing the right thing.
With Assets under Management and Administration up 7%, of which 1% is attributable to net inflows, revenue increased by 3%. Thanks to costs decreasing by 3% as the group focused on profitability, adjusted profit before tax was up 25%.
It’s interesting to see how financial distortions come through. HEPS has actually fallen severely from 12.6 pence to 3.2 pence, yet adjusted diluted earnings per share increased from 7.9 pence to 9.4 pence. The difference seems to be due to policyholder tax outcomes.
Cash, as always, is king. The dividend per share moved higher from 4.5 pence to 5.2 pence. The share price is roughly 25% higher over the past 12 months.
Finance costs eat up the profits at Sea Harvest (JSE: SHG)
Yet another example of banks getting the benefit of corporate growth
At Sea Harvest, we can see an income statement profile that has played out in many corporates in the past year.
Revenue increased by 6% and gross profit was up 13%, which is great as this means that gross profit margin moved higher. The theme here is improved pricing that more than offset lower sales volumes. The weak rand also plays a role here.
None of it helped at operating profit level sadly, which fell 2%. Load shedding related costs jumped from R25 million to R46 million for the year.
We then arrive at the net finance costs line, which jumped by a whopping 79%. This is a combination of interest rates being much higher than the previous year, along with higher average borrowing levels.
Thanks to the bankers getting such a great outcome, HEPS was down 5%. Despite this, the final dividend moved higher from 38 cents to 40 cents per share.
Looking ahead, the South African business will look to take advantage of the 5% increase in the Total Allowable Catch. The rest of the business will focus on managing the usual supply-demand fluctuations in the broader seafood market. And of course, there will be a lot of attention on the deal to acquire 100% of Terrasan’s pelagic fish business and 63.07% of Terrasan’s abalone business.
Little Bites:
Director dealings:
In a very unusual transaction, directors of Stor-Age (JSE: SSS) have been able to sell shares that were acquired via a scheme that included an interest-bearing loan from the company. This is a typical structure in the property sector, with dividends on the shares applied against the interest. What makes this unusual is that an institutional shareholder has made an offer to the directors to buy their shares under the scheme, thereby allowing them to settle the debt and pocket the difference. The price for the trade is R14, which is only slightly below the current market price. Three directors sold a collective R104 million worth of shares in this trade.
As part of a funding transaction with a financial institution, CEO of Sibanye-Stillwater (JSE: SSW) Neal Froneman exercised a put option to sell R96.4 million worth of shares in the company at R66.24 per share. For context, the current share price is R19.50!
A director of Gold Fields (JSE: GFI) sold shares worth R11.75 million. These are vested performance shares all the shares were sold, not just the portion to settle taxes.
Lighthouse (JSE: LTE) has sold shares in Hammerson worth just over R1 billion. This unlocks a lot of capital for Lighthouse to pursue yield-accretive direct property acquisitions.
MTN Uganda (JSE: MTN) released results for the year ended December 2023. Service revenue increased by 16.1% and EBITDA was up 16.3%, so at least margins are consistent. Capital expenditure moved 5.5% higher and the final dividend was 16.4% higher. This is a better trend than we’ve seen in MTN’s other African subsidiaries.
Eastern Platinum (JSE: EPS) announced that the initial soft start of the Zandfontein underground operations at the Crocodile River Mine is now fully operational. They will now focus on ramping up underground efforts and bringing material to the surface, with the first batch of run-of-mine processing scheduled for the second quarter of this year. The goal is to achieve a mining run rate of 40,000 tons per month by the end of 2024.
Clientele (JSE: CLI) has appointed Angela Pillay as Executive Financial Director. She has extensive experience in financial services.
It says something about the maturity and strategic direction of Jubilee Metals (JSE: JBL) that the company has appointed formal boards for both the South African and Zambian businesses. Separately, the company announced that an option holder will exercise 9 million options at an average price of 2.11 pence per option, so be careful of ongoing dilution here.
The end is nigh at Ellies (JSE: ELI), with the latest news being the resignation of the CFO and an independent non-executive director.
Afristrat (JSE: ATI) will proceed with a liquidation application as the company is commercially insolvent.
Luxe Holdings eventually put us all out of its misery by delisting in November 2023. This hasn’t stopped the JSE from issuing a public censure and fine of R7.5 million against Helena Dorothea Grewar, who was CEO at the time. She sold shares worth R12 million in the closed period, which absolutely isn’t allowed. To make it worse, the JSE says she didn’t even engage with regulatory correspondence, which isn’t a smart strategy. On top of the fine, she has been disqualified from holding office as a director of any JSE listed company for a period of 5 years.
Get the latest recap of JSE news in the Ghost Wrap podcast, brought to you by Mazars:
Curro hasn’t been shy with fee increases (JSE: COH)
The financial impact is positive for now, at least
The South African middle class is finding things very difficult right now. Curro is also finding it rather tricky to fill the schools that have been built, perhaps because of these problems plaguing the middle class. In a rather risky strategy from a long-term perspective, Curro seems to be addressing the issue of empty seats by hiking fees where there is a bum on a chair, putting even more pressure on those consumers.
Tuition fees increased by 12%, driving a revenue increase of 15%. The weighted average number of learners only increased by 2%. The rest of the revenue growth is explained by ancillary revenue, which was 33% higher.
Don’t be fooled into thinking that the teachers are getting rich. Employee costs were up 7% and other costs increased by 19% (both on a like-for-like basis).
This means that margins moved sharply higher, with EBITDA up 25% net of head office expenditure. HEPS increased by 19%. Recurring HEPS increased by 32%.
Cash from operating activities only increased by 9%, so the balance sheet has some catching up to do to the income statement performance.
When you consider the extent of tuition fee increases, it’s surprising that Curro makes the statement that the primary focus in the short to medium term is to support and increase the capacity utilisation of existing facilities. That goal doesn’t sound congruent with an approach of above-inflation fee hikes. I worry about how sustainable this approach is.
The MultiChoice offer is up to R125 a share (JSE: MCG)
This is an interesting structure
If you’ve been following the news around MultiChoice, you’ll know that Canal+ needs to make a mandatory offer to shareholders of MultiChoice. The price would’ve been around R105 per share, but to try and expedite the process of a transaction, Canal+ has increased it to R125 per share and MultiChoice has agreed to cooperate in this regard.
Although we don’t know for sure yet, this implies that the MultiChoice independent board is more likely to support this offer than the last one. Having said that, they’ve behaved in an unpredictable manner before. Anything is possible.
Nedbank hit a number of key targets in 2023 (JSE: NED)
Growth in the final dividend of 18% is a solid outcome for investors
Nedbank’s share price enjoyed a strong day on the market, closing 3.3% higher in response to a strong set of numbers for the year ended December 2023. Goodness knows it was a tough year for the economy, with banks reaping the rewards of higher interest rates and larger balance sheets from inflation. There weren’t many winners in the economy outside of the banks!
Nedbank managed to grow revenue for the year by 12%, with net interest income up 14%, non-interest revenue up 6% and associate income up 64%. A 30% jump in impairments blunted the growth at HEPS level, which came in at 11%. The positive surprise here was that the credit loss ratio improved significantly in the second half of the year, coming in at 109 basis points for the full year vs. 121 basis points in the interim period.
This strong end to the year saw Nedbank meet several key financial targets, including a return on equity ahead of the cost of equity (15.1% vs. 15%) and a cost-to-income ratio below 54.0%.
Thanks to these efforts, the final dividend is up 18% at a payout ratio of 57%. The full-year dividend is 15% higher than the prior year.
After a 14-year innings, Mike Brown steps down as CEO and hands over to Jason Quinn. Having had the pleasure of engaging with Mike very early in my banking career, I know that he did an excellent job of navigating an exceptionally disappointing period for the South African economy. Quinn will need to make sure his old red ties are right at the back of the cupboard, with only green ties coming out as he leads the bank through a period that doesn’t look to be getting any simpler in our country.
Premier is on track for a maiden dividend (JSE: PMR)
The focus has been on reducing debt and improving the balance sheet
With Premier attending the Bank of America Sun City conference this week, the company has released an update on recent trading performance.
After the first six months of the year showed the slightest growth in HEPS (up 0.8% despite revenue being up 7.1%), investors couldn’t exactly have been expecting a rocketship for the second half of the year. Indeed, as inflation in soft commodities has settled down, revenue growth has moderated to low single digits.
This means that Premier has focused on maintaining margins, which are in line with the margins for the first six months of the financial year.
Interestingly, the company isn’t pulling back on organic investment opportunities. In fact, capital expenditure for the second half of the financial year is expected to be higher than guidance.
Despite the higher capex, the company has focused on reducing debt on the balance sheet and improving its leverage ratio. The company believes that it is on track to pay a maiden final dividend for the year ending March 2024.
Market share gains yet again for Shoprite (JSE: SHP)
If only we had a reliable electricity supply…
The snowball effect in the grocery market is quite something to witness, with Shoprite continuing to charge forwards and Pick n Pay whimpering in the corner. Somehow, Spar manages to eek out a living and Woolworths is trying to remain relevant to consumers by being more aggressive on price. It’s rather hectic out there.
After strong growth in sales in Supermarkets RSA of 17.5% last year, a 14.6% increase in sales in the latest interim period is an impressive result. The rest of the market could only manage growth of 7.6%, according to NielsenIQ data quoted by Shoprite.
The main thing that has continued to impress me is Shoprite’s ability to grow at every part of the income curve. Everyone talks about Checkers this and Checkers that, yet Shoprite and Usave casually increased sales by 13.1%. They have done some astonishing things in that business to create meal solutions for very low income workers. Checkers and Checkers Hyper grew by 13.7%, so as great as Checkers is, it doesn’t deserve all the attention.
Checkers Sixty60 grew by 63.1%, so the turquoise scooter army rides on.
Taking a geographical view, Supermarkets non-RSA grew 6.2% and Supermarkets RSA grew 14.6%, so the group’s decision to focus on winning in the South African market is paying off. Within the local business, customer visits were up 6.4% and average basket spend increased 7.7%, so Shoprite is winning the sales volumes war at a time when most FMCG businesses in South Africa are only achieving growth through hiking prices.
Gross margin increased ever so slightly from 23.5% to 23.6%, with higher volumes through the tills creating efficiencies back in the supply chain.
Unfortunately, the broader operating conditions (read: load shedding) really blunted the benefit of this sales growth by the time we reach the profit lines on the income statement. Trading profit was up 10.7%, with trading margin down 20 basis points to 5.5% due to R500 million spent on diesel for generators.
Thanks to Eskom, operating profit was up by “only” 8.1%, despite the substantial growth in sales. You can now clearly see why competitor Pick n Pay is getting crushed at the moment, with modest sales growth and the same expense pressures.
Profit after tax only grew by 4.2% at Shoprite and HEPS was up 7.3%, with the dividend per share up by 7.7% as the payout ratio was increased.
For the first six weeks of new financial period (the second half of 2024), Supermarkets RSA has grown 10%. Inflation has slowed down from 7.7% to 5.3%, so that should cause a dip in the growth rate. Shoprite is also quick to remind investors that they are lapping a very strong base.
Sibanye-Stillwater hopes for better PGM prices (JSE: SSW)
The company believes that price weakness in PGMs is temporary rather than structural
Sibanye has certainly had a year to forget, with a massive decrease in the share price as the PGM market fell apart. Revenue for the full year was 18% lower than in 2022, with nickel prices also doing their fair share of damage.
The loss for the period was a colossal R37.4 billion. The good news is that non-cash impairments were R47.5 billion, so the cash situation wasn’t anywhere near that bad. Still, there’s no final dividend, so the full-year dividend was entirely comprised of the interim dividend of 53 cents per share.
If there are any highlights here, it’s that net debt to adjusted EBITDA is 0.58x. The other highlight is the turnaround in the gold operations, helped of course by the higher gold price. The gold operation is too small to save the day by itself though, particularly when you compare its EBITDA for the six months to December (positive R1.148bn) to the losses in the nickel business of R701 million. The net contribution is very small relative to the PGM operations.
In other words, for Sibanye to work out, the PGM price needs to move heavily in the right direction. The recent shift in sentiment away from battery electric vehicles could help here. This is why I’ve very gingerly topped up my PGM exposure in literally the past week, as I think the hype around EVs is finally starting to do what I believed would always happen: disappear.
I’m well aware that any PGM position requires an extremely strong stomach and modest position sizing.
WBHO declares an interim dividend (JSE: WBO)
There is a substantial improvement in profitability at WBHO
Construction companies have a long sales cycle. They first need to secure a strong order book before revenue starts to flow in, so investors have to be patient. The efforts in the order book in the prior period have paid off at WBHO for the six months to December 2023, with revenue from continuing operations up 29% and HEPS coming in at 897 cents vs. 630 cents in the comparable period (growth of 42%).
The net asset value of the group has jumped from R3.3 billion to R4.4 billion. In further good news, the strong order book is still there, sitting at R32.3 billion vs. R32.6 billion as at June 2023.
This has allowed the group to declare an interim dividend of 230 cents per share vs. no interim dividend in the comparable period.
Little Bites:
Director dealings:
The CEO of Bidcorp (JSE: BID) has sold a substantial R26.7 million worth of shares in the company. After the run in the price over the past couple of years, I would take careful note of this.
The outgoing CEO of Aveng (JSE: AEG) sold all the share options that vested on early retirement, for a total of almost R4.4 million. That counts as a sale in my book, as executives usually only sell the portion required to pay the tax.
Gold Fields (JSE: GFI) has finalised the sale of its 45% interest in Asanko Gold Mine for gross proceeds of $170 million plus a 1% net smelter royalty. $65 million in cash has been received, as well as shares in the acquirer Galiano Gold. The balance of the price is receivable over the next couple of years.
There is very little liquidity in Putprop (JSE: PRR) so I’ll give the latest financial results a passing mention here. The company owns a portfolio of 13 properties. Net asset value moved from R16.14 to R16.29 over the past year. The dividend per share increased from 4.25 cents to 6 cents.
If you are interested in Omnia (JSE: OMN), then the company’s presentation at the Bank of America Global Research 25th Annual Sun City Conference 2024 (yes, it’s that much of a mouthful) will be useful for you to read. You can find it here.
Libstar (JSE: LBR) released a trading statement that has an update to the HEPS guidance based on the exclusion of insurance proceeds from the Denny fire incident. Total HEPS (without adjustments for this issue) will be between 3.5% and 8.5% higher for the year ended December 2023.
The dilution continues for shareholders in Kibo Energy (JSE: KBO), with the company issuing shares worth £30k to settle a service provider’s outstanding invoices.
Annual Results for the year ended 31 December 2023
All 2023 targets met – a strong foundation from which we shift focus to deliver on our medium-term targets.
While we were pleased to have achieved all our 2023 targets while operating in a more difficult economic environment, we aspire to deliver ongoing improvements in ROE to increase shareholder value. Our strong financial performance in 2023, together with the progress made in executing on our strategy and underlying momentum in the business, gives us confidence in delivering on our medium-term targets* and, in particular, our aim to increase our ROE to 17% by 2025 and above 18% in the long term.
Nedbank Group is one of South Africa’s four largest banks, with Nedbank Limited as their principal banking subsidiary.
They offer the following solutions through their frontline clusters, Nedbank Corporate and Investment Banking, Nedbank Retail and Business Banking, Nedbank Wealth and Nedbank Africa Regions: – a wide range of wholesale and retain banking services – a growing insurance
We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously.
Cookie
Duration
Description
cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics
11 months
This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional
11 months
The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary
11 months
This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-others
11 months
This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other.
cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance
11 months
This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance".
viewed_cookie_policy
11 months
The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data.
Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
